Startup Registration vs MSME Registration: Key Differences Explained

What Is a Dormant Company?

Under the Companies Act, 2013, a dormant company refers to an entity that is temporarily inactive, with no significant accounting transactions during a financial year. The definition of a dormant company encompasses companies that are:

• Incorporated for future projects
  
• Established to hold assets or intellectual property
  
• Not engaged in any significant financial transactions
  

To be eligible for dormant company status, a company must meet the following criteria:

• No significant accounting transactions during the last two financial years
  
• No filing of financial statements and annual returns with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) in the preceding two financial years
  

It's important to note that a company can remain dormant for a maximum of five consecutive financial years. After this period, the company must either commence operations or apply for an extension of dormant status with the ROC.

Is a Dormant Company Allowed To Trade?

A dormant company is not allowed to conduct significant business transactions, such as:

• Buying or selling goods and services
  
• Engaging in revenue-generating operations
  
• Undertaking any other form of trade
  

However, a dormant company can carry out certain essential activities, including:

• Paying fees and fulfilling compliance requirements under the Companies Act or other applicable laws
  
• Maintaining its registered office and records
  
• Allotting shares to shareholders
  

Engaging in active trading or substantial business transactions may lead to the loss of dormant company status. Therefore, it is crucial for business owners to ensure that their dormant company remains compliant with the prescribed regulations.

A Brief Overview of Dormant Status Under the Companies Act 2013

Section 455 of the Companies Act 2013 introduced the concept of dormant companies to provide a legal framework for businesses that wish to temporarily suspend their operations while maintaining their legal status. This provision allows companies to:

• Preserve their assets and intellectual property
  
• Reduce compliance costs during periods of inactivity
  
• Keep their company name reserved for future projects
  

Meaning of Inactive Company

An inactive company, as per the Companies Act 2013, is a company that:

• Has not conducted any significant financial transactions during the last two financial years
  
• Has not filed financial statements and annual returns with the ROC for the preceding two financial years
  

Reasons for Obtaining the Status of a Dormant Company

There are several reasons why a company may choose to obtain dormant company status:

• To preserve the company name for future business ventures
  
• To hold assets or intellectual property without actively engaging in business operations
  
• To reduce compliance costs and regulatory burdens during periods of inactivity
  
• To facilitate business restructuring or strategic planning
  
• To maintain legal status while the promoters or directors are unavailable due to personal reasons, such as illness, travel, or sabbatical
  

Top 5 Benefits of Opting for Dormant Company Status

1. Reduced Compliance Requirements: Dormant companies are subject to significantly fewer compliance obligations under the Companies Act 2013. This includes exemptions from holding frequent board meetings, appointing auditors, and filing detailed annual returns.
   
2. Cost Savings: By reducing compliance requirements, dormant companies can save on administrative expenses, such as auditor fees, legal costs, and filing charges. This can be particularly beneficial for small businesses and start-ups looking to minimise overhead costs.
   
3. Brand Name Protection: Registering as a dormant company allows businesses to protect their brand name and prevent others from registering a similar name. This is crucial for companies that have invested in building a strong brand identity and want to preserve it for future use.
   
4. Flexibility for Future Business Plans: Dormant company status provides businesses with the flexibility to reactivate their operations when the time is right. This can be particularly useful for companies that are waiting for market conditions to improve or for key personnel to return from extended absences.
   
5. Simplified Annual Filings: Dormant companies are required to file a simplified version of the annual return, known as Form MSC-3. This form requires less detailed information compared to the annual returns filed by active companies, reducing the administrative burden on business owners.
   

By weighing the benefits of dormant company status against the specific needs and goals of their business, entrepreneurs can make informed decisions about whether this legal structure is suitable for their situation.

Mandatory Requirements for Obtaining Dormant Status

To be eligible for dormant company status under Section 455 of the Companies Act 2013, a company must fulfil certain mandatory requirements:

1. No Significant Accounting Transactions: The company must not have carried out any significant accounting transactions during the financial year for which dormant status is sought. This excludes transactions related to the allotment of shares, payment of fees to the ROC, and maintenance of the company's office and records.
2. No Outstanding Liabilities: The company must not have any outstanding loans, whether secured or unsecured, or any other outstanding liabilities. If there are any outstanding unsecured loans, the company must obtain a no-objection certificate from the lenders before applying for dormant status.
3. No Pending Regulatory Actions: There should be no pending inspections, inquiries, or investigations against the company by any regulatory authorities. Additionally, no prosecution proceedings should be initiated against the company under any law.
4. Up-to-date Statutory Filings: The company must have filed all its pending returns, including annual returns and financial statements, with the ROC before applying for dormant status.
5. Shareholder Approval: The company must obtain approval from its shareholders through a special resolution passed at a general meeting. Alternatively, the company can obtain the consent of at least 3/4th of its shareholders by value through a written resolution.

How to File for Dormant Status: A Step-By-Step Guide

Filing for dormant company status involves a series of steps that must be followed in accordance with the provisions of the Companies Act 2013:

1. Convene a Board Meeting: The company's board of directors must convene a meeting to discuss and approve the proposal for obtaining dormant status. The board resolution should authorise the filing of the necessary application and documents with the ROC.
2. Obtain Shareholder Approval: The company must obtain approval from its shareholders either through a special resolution passed at a general meeting or through the written consent of at least 3/4th of the shareholders by value.
3. Prepare the Statement of Affairs: The company must prepare a statement of affairs, including a balance sheet and profit and loss account, as of the date of the application for dormant status. This statement should be verified by an affidavit from the company's directors.
4. File Form MSC-1: The company must file Form MSC-1 with the ROC, along with the necessary supporting documents, including the board resolution, shareholder approval, statement of affairs, and any other relevant documents as specified in the Companies Act 2013.
5. Pay the Prescribed Fees: The company must pay the prescribed fees for filing Form MSC-1, as specified in the Companies (Registration Offices and Fees) Rules, 2014.
6. Obtain Certificate of Dormant Status: Upon verification of the application and supporting documents, the ROC will issue a certificate of dormant status to the company in Form MSC-2.

It is important to note that the entire process of filing for dormant company status must be completed within 30 days of obtaining shareholder approval. Companies should seek the assistance of a qualified professional, such as a company secretary or chartered accountant, to ensure compliance with the prescribed procedures and timelines.

ROC Forms for Registering Dormant Company

• Form MSC-1: This form is used to apply for obtaining dormant company status. It must be filed with the ROC within 30 days of obtaining shareholder approval. The form requires details such as the company's name, registered office address, directors' particulars, and the reasons for seeking dormant status.
• Form MSC-3: This form is used to file the annual return of a dormant company. It must be filed within 30 days from the end of each financial year. The form requires details such as the company's financial position, shareholding pattern, and any changes in the directors' or registered office address.
• Form MSC-4: This form is used to apply for seeking the status of an active company. It must be filed with the ROC when a dormant company wants to commence business operations. The form requires details such as the company's name, registered office address, and the reasons for seeking active status.

Annual Compliance for Dormant Company

While dormant companies enjoy certain relaxations under the Companies Act 2013, they are still required to fulfil essential annual compliance tasks in four key areas:

1. Accounting and Financial Statements: Dormant companies must maintain proper books of accounts and prepare financial statements, including a balance sheet and profit and loss account, for each financial year. These financial statements must be approved by the board of directors and presented at the annual general meeting.
   
2. Statutory Audit: Dormant companies are required to appoint a statutory auditor to conduct an audit of their financial statements. However, dormant companies are exempt from the requirement of auditor rotation, which is mandatory for active companies.
3. Tax Return Filings: Dormant companies must file their income tax returns annually, even if they have not generated any income during the financial year. They are also required to comply with other applicable tax laws, such as the Goods and Services Tax (GST) and Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) provisions.
4. ROC Filings: Dormant companies must file an annual return in Form MSC-3 with the ROC within 30 days from the end of each financial year. This form requires details such as the company's financial position, shareholding pattern, and any changes in the directors' or registered office address.

By fulfilling these annual compliance requirements, dormant companies can ensure that they remain in good standing with the regulatory authorities and avoid any penalties or legal consequences.

Reactivation of a Dormant Company

A dormant company can be reactivated and commence business operations by following the prescribed procedure under the Companies Act 2013:

1. Convene a Board Meeting: The company's board of directors must convene a meeting to discuss and approve the proposal for reactivating the company. The board resolution should authorise the filing of the necessary application and documents with the ROC.
2. File Form MSC-4: The company must file Form MSC-4 with the ROC, along with the necessary supporting documents, including the board resolution and any other relevant documents as specified in the Companies Act 2013.
3. Pay the Prescribed Fees: The company must pay the prescribed fees for filing Form MSC-4, as specified in the Companies (Registration Offices and Fees) Rules, 2014.
4. Obtain Certificate of Active Status: Upon verification of the application and supporting documents, the ROC will issue a certificate of active status to the company in Form MSC-5.

Once the company has obtained the certificate of active status, it can commence business operations and is required to comply with all the provisions of the Companies Act 2013 applicable to active companies, including regular compliance requirements such as holding board meetings, filing annual returns, and appointing auditors.

Conclusion

Dormant company under Section 455 of the Companies Act 2013 is a strategic tool for businesses to preserve their legal identity while suspending operations. It allows companies to protect their brand name, reduce compliance costs, and maintain flexibility for future ventures. To benefit from this status, businesses must meet eligibility criteria and comply with statutory requirements. Seeking professional assistance is advisable to navigate the process effectively and avoid legal issues. This approach is ideal for future projects, asset holding, or temporary business pauses, offering a cost-effective solution for maintaining legal existence.

Frequently Asked Questions

Key Differences Between D2C and B2C

Below is a structured comparison of D2C and B2C business models:

Understanding D2C (Direct-to-Consumer)

The Direct-to-Consumer (D2C) model is transforming the way brands connect with customers by eliminating middlemen such as wholesalers, retailers, and marketplaces. Instead of relying on third-party distributors, D2C brands sell directly to their consumers, allowing them to maintain greater control over pricing, branding, customer experience, and marketing.

This model has gained immense popularity due to advancements in e-commerce, digital marketing, and consumer behaviour shifts, where people prefer personalised shopping experiences and direct engagement with brands.

Key Characteristics of D2C

• Direct sales to customers, bypassing intermediaries.
  
• High reliance on digital marketing and social media.
  
• Personalised customer experience and strong brand identity.
  
• Subscription-based or direct-selling models.
  

How Does D2C Work?

D2C businesses follow a structured approach to take products from concept to consumer while optimising every step for efficiency and customer satisfaction.

1. Product Development – Companies design and manufacture their products.
   
2. Branding & Marketing – Strong online presence, leveraging social media and influencers.
   
3. Sales & Distribution – Selling through their websites, pop-up stores, or direct retail.
   
4. Customer Engagement – Providing personalised service and direct interactions.
   

D2C Example

A great example of a successful D2C brand is Nike. While Nike does sell through retailers, it has aggressively expanded its direct-to-consumer channels through its website, exclusive stores, and apps, allowing for greater control over branding, pricing, and customer experience.

Understanding B2C (Business-to-Consumer)

The Business-to-Consumer (B2C) model is one of the most common and traditional business structures, where companies sell products or services directly to individual customers. B2C businesses can operate through brick-and-mortar stores, e-commerce platforms, third-party marketplaces, and direct retail chains.

This model focuses on high-volume sales, competitive pricing, and broad customer reach. Unlike D2C brands, which manage their own sales channels, B2C companies often partner with retailers and online marketplaces to distribute their products.

Key Characteristics of D2C

• Direct sales to customers, bypassing intermediaries.
  
• High reliance on digital marketing and social media.
  
• Personalised customer experience and strong brand identity.
  
• Subscription-based or direct-selling models.
  

How Does D2C Work?

D2C businesses follow a structured approach to take products from concept to consumer while optimising every step for efficiency and customer satisfaction.

1. Product Development – Companies design and manufacture their products.
   
2. Branding & Marketing – Strong online presence, leveraging social media and influencers.
   
3. Sales & Distribution – Selling through their websites, pop-up stores, or direct retail.
   
4. Customer Engagement – Providing personalised service and direct interactions.
   

B2C Example

A classic example of a B2C business is Amazon. Amazon provides a vast range of products from multiple sellers, offering convenience and variety to end consumers without directly manufacturing most of the products it sells.

Top 5 Benefits of D2C

1. Higher Profit Margins – Eliminates middlemen, allowing businesses to retain higher revenues.
   
2. Direct Customer Insights – Enables data collection for better personalisation and marketing.
   
3. Better Brand Control – Full control over branding, messaging, and customer experience.
   
4. Efficient Inventory Management – Greater flexibility in managing stock and production.
   
5. Stronger Customer Relationships – Builds brand loyalty through direct interactions.
   

5 Limitations of D2C You Can’t Ignore

1. High Customer Acquisition Costs – Digital advertising and influencer marketing can be expensive.
   
2. Intense Competition – Direct sales require brands to stand out in a crowded market.
   
3. Logistics and Fulfillment Challenges – Managing deliveries and returns can be complex.
   
4. Reliance on Digital Marketing – Success depends on strong online marketing strategies.
   
5. Customer Service Demands – Requires robust support teams to handle queries and complaints.
   

5 Incredible Benefits of B2C

1. Larger Customer Base – Mass-market appeal leads to high sales volume.
   
2. Faster Sales Cycles – Quick purchase decisions without prolonged relationship-building.
   
3. Lower Operational Costs – Retailers handle distribution, reducing overhead expenses.
   
4. Multiple Sales Channels – Products available in stores, online, and via third-party platforms.
   
5. Increased Brand Visibility – Established brands enjoy widespread recognition.
   

5 Major Drawbacks of B2C You Need To Know

1. High Competition – Many brands compete for the same audience.
   
2. Lower Customer Loyalty – Customers may switch brands based on price or availability.
   
3. Price Sensitivity – Discounts and competitive pricing play a significant role.
   
4. Increased Marketing Costs – Requires large advertising budgets to stay competitive.
   
5. Logistical Challenges – Managing supply chains across multiple locations can be complex.
   

Choosing Between D2C and B2C

Selecting the right business model depends on various factors, including brand strategy, market reach, and operational capabilities. Here’s a breakdown to help businesses decide between Direct-to-Consumer (D2C) and Business-to-Consumer (B2C):

1. Business Goals

• D2C is ideal for brands that want full control over branding, pricing, and customer relationships. It allows companies to build a loyal customer base and gather first-party data for personalised marketing.
  
• B2C works well for businesses that prioritise high-volume sales and broad market penetration. It enables companies to leverage retailer networks for distribution and scalability.
  

2. Target Audience

• D2C is more suited for niche markets, such as luxury products, sustainable goods, or tech gadgets, where direct customer engagement is crucial.
  
• B2C caters to a mass-market audience, making it ideal for FMCG (Fast-Moving Consumer Goods), electronics, fashion, and essential consumer products.
  

3. Marketing Approach

• D2C relies heavily on digital marketing, influencer collaborations, and social media engagement. Brands must invest in performance marketing (SEO, PPC, email campaigns) to attract and retain customers.
  
• B2C focuses on mass advertising through traditional media (TV, print, billboards), large-scale promotions, and brand partnerships to maximise reach.
  

4. Operational Capabilities

• D2C demands robust logistics, warehousing, and last-mile delivery capabilities since brands manage order fulfilment directly.
  
• B2C benefits from retailer partnerships that handle inventory, distribution, and customer service, reducing operational complexity.
  

5. Profitability Model

• D2C offers higher profit margins since it eliminates middlemen. However, it requires a significant initial investment in technology, marketing, and fulfilment infrastructure.
  
• B2C generates revenue through bulk sales and retailer partnerships. While margins may be lower, brands benefit from established distribution networks and faster scalability.
  

How Razorpay Rize Empowers D2C and B2C Businesses

Razorpay Rize is a dedicated ecosystem designed to support and accelerate the growth of both D2C and B2C businesses. Whether you're a startup launching a direct-to-consumer brand or a scaling business selling through retailers, Rize provides the essential tools, resources, and community support to help you succeed.

• Company Registration Assistance
  
• Exclusive Community for D2C Founders
  
• Tools & Deals to Boost Business Growth
  

Conclusion

Both D2C and B2C models have unique advantages and challenges. Understanding these key differences helps businesses make informed decisions about their go-to-market strategies.

For brands that prioritise control over branding, pricing, and customer experience, D2C offers the perfect route by cutting out intermediaries and selling directly to consumers. It allows for personalised engagement, higher profit margins, and data-driven marketing strategies.

On the other hand, the B2C model benefits from wide-scale distribution, existing retail networks, and established consumer trust. Businesses leveraging third-party marketplaces, physical retail stores, and large-scale advertising campaigns can reach a broader audience quickly.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Equity Dilution?

Equity dilution refers to the reduction in existing shareholders’ ownership percentage due to the issuance of new shares. Although it doesn't necessarily mean a loss in actual monetary value, it does mean reduced voting power, ownership stake, and potential control over the company.

For example, if a founder owns 50% of a company before a funding round and 40% after new shares are issued to investors, the 10% drop is equity dilution.

Causes of Equity Dilution in India

Several scenarios in India lead to equity dilution:

• Fundraising through equity: When a company raises capital by issuing new shares to investors (angel, VC, PE).
• ESOPs (Employee Stock Option Plans): Issuing shares to employees for retention and motivation.
• Convertible instruments: When convertible debentures or notes convert to equity.
• Mergers and acquisitions: New shares issued as part of a transaction.
• Bonus or rights issues: Depending on the structure, these can also dilute holdings if not proportionally subscribed.

Impact of Equity Dilution

Dilution can affect stakeholders in various ways:

• Founders: Loss of control or voting power if too much equity is given away early.
• Investors: Reduced ownership percentages, which may affect decision-making influence.
• Employees: If ESOPs are diluted too often, their potential upside gets reduced.
• Company valuation: Though dilution reduces percentage ownership, it can lead to growth and higher valuations, offsetting the effect in monetary terms.

How Does Share Dilution Happen?

Share dilution occurs when a company issues additional shares, reducing the ownership percentage of existing shareholders. While the total number of shares increases, each existing shareholder’s slice of the pie becomes smaller — unless they participate in the new issue.

Here are the most common ways share dilution happens in India:

1. Fundraising (Equity Rounds)

During seed, Series A, or later funding rounds, new investors are issued fresh equity. To accommodate them, the company increases its authorised and paid-up share capital, diluting the percentage held by existing shareholders.

Example:
A founder owns 100% of a startup with 1,00,000 shares. After raising funds from investors who are issuing 50,000 new shares, the founder’s ownership drops to 66.67%.

2. Issuing ESOPs (Employee Stock Option Plans)

Startups often set aside 5–15% of their cap table for ESOPs to attract and retain top talent. These options, once vested and exercised, convert into shares — reducing the percentage stake of other shareholders.

3. Conversion of Convertible Instruments

Instruments like convertible notes, SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity), or CCDs (Compulsorily Convertible Debentures) convert into equity at a future date. When they convert, new shares are issued, which dilute existing ownership.

4. Mergers or Acquisitions

In some mergers or acquisitions, equity may be offered as part of the consideration to the merging entity or its shareholders. This leads to the issuance of new shares and causes dilution.

5. Bonus Shares to Select Stakeholders

Occasionally, a company might issue bonus shares to certain shareholders or employees as incentives, which can result in uneven dilution.

Reasons for Equity Dilution

• Capital infusion: To fund growth, R&D, hiring, marketing, etc.
• Strategic partnerships: Issuing equity to partners or advisors.
• Debt conversion: Debt turning into equity through convertible notes.
• Regulatory compliance: SEBI regulations may require public companies to maintain a certain free float, triggering new issuance.

Managing Equity Dilution in India

Equity dilution is inevitable as your startup grows — but managing it smartly can protect both your control and long-term value. Indian founders must understand the tools, strategies, and legal frameworks available to reduce unnecessary dilution and align all stakeholders.

1. Plan Your Cap Table Early

Create a 5–7 year cap table projection. Visualise future funding rounds, ESOP pools, convertible instruments, and expected dilution at each stage.

2. Raise What You Need, Not What You Can

Avoid over-raising in early rounds. Each round of funding comes at the cost of equity. Only raise what’s required to hit the next set of milestones.

3. Negotiate Better Valuations

Valuation is key to how much equity you give up. Strengthen your fundamentals, traction, and pitch to negotiate higher valuations, thus minimising dilution per rupee raised.

4. Use Convertible Instruments Strategically

Instruments like SAFE notes or CCDs can delay dilution until a priced round. Use them in early or bridge rounds to preserve equity while bringing in capital.

5. Be Thoughtful with ESOP Allocation

ESOPs are critical to building a strong team, but don’t over-allocate too early. Start with a lean pool (5–10%) and expand as your team grows and funding allows.

6. Include Anti-Dilution Provisions (If You're an Investor or Co-Founder)

While often investor-friendly, certain anti-dilution clauses can protect your equity in down rounds. Founders should understand these clauses and negotiate fair terms.

7. Consider Non-Dilutive Capital

Explore grants, government schemes (like Startup India Seed Fund, MeitY TIDE, or NIDHI), or revenue-based financing. These options offer capital with no equity dilution.

8. Maintain Founder Alignment

If co-founders have significantly unequal stakes, align expectations early. Future dilution can compound tensions if not addressed at the start.

How Shareholders Can Handle Equity Dilution?

• Pre-emptive rights: Ensure agreements include rights to participate in future rounds to maintain shareholding.
• Anti-dilution clauses: Particularly for investors, these can protect them from value dilution in down rounds.
• Monitor ESOP pools: Oversized ESOP pools dilute all shareholders.
• Regular cap table reviews: Stay updated to avoid surprises in ownership shifts.

Conclusion

Equity dilution is a natural part of a growing business, especially in India's thriving startup and investment landscape. While it may seem negative on the surface, it often enables access to capital, talent, and partnerships that fuel long-term value creation. 

The key lies in understanding, planning, and strategically managing dilution to protect stakeholder interests while supporting the company’s growth.

‍