Private Limited Company Vs. Limited Liability Partnerships (LLP): Key Differences

What are Small Companies?

Small companies, as defined by the Companies Act 2013, are private limited businesses with lower annual revenue compared to regular-sized companies. They follow the same registration process as private limited companies but have distinct financial criteria. To be classified as a small company as per the Companies Act, a business must meet the revised thresholds for paid-up capital and turnover.

The significance of small companies in India's economy cannot be overstated. They contribute to profit generation and job creation, making them essential drivers of economic growth. By providing goods and services to local communities and niche markets, small companies help foster inclusive development across the country.

The New Definition of Small Company

A small company is now defined as a non-public entity as per the Companies (Specification of Definition details) Amendment Rules, 2022, effective from 15 September 2022, if it meets the following conditions:

• Small company paid-up capital should not exceed ₹4 Crores, or such higher amount specified, which should not exceed ₹10 Crores.
• Small company turnover limit should not exceed ₹40 Crores, or such higher amount specified, which should not exceed ₹100 Crores.

It is important to note that certain companies are excluded from being classified as small companies, even if they meet the above criteria. These include:

• Public companies
• Holding companies
• Subsidiary companies
• Companies registered under Section 8 (non-profit companies)
• Companies governed by any special act

The 2022 amendment significantly broadened the scope for small companies, enhancing their eligibility for benefits and simplifying compliance requirements, thus fostering growth in the small business sector in India.

Earlier Definition of Small Companies 2021

Prior to the 2022 amendment, the definition of small companies underwent changes in 2021. The thresholds for paid-up capital and turnover were revised as follows:

Comparing Small Company New Definition with Old Definitions

The Companies (Specification of Definition details) Amendment Rules, 2022, have further expanded the scope of small companies by increasing the limits for paid-up share capital and turnover. Here's a comparison of the key changes between the old and new definitions:

The increased thresholds allow more firms to be classified as small companies and avail of the benefits provided under the Companies Act 2013. This expansion is expected to reduce compliance burdens and facilitate ease of doing business for a larger number of small businesses in India.

Benefits of Revised Small Company Definition

Exemption from Preparing Cash Flow Statements

Small companies are not required to include cash flow statements in their financial reports, simplifying their accounting processes.

Simplified Annual Filings

They can prepare and file an abridged annual return, reducing administrative workload.

Fewer Board Meeting Requirements: 

Small companies are mandated to hold only two board meetings per year instead of four, which lessens operational demands.

Impact on Audit Processes

1. Auditors are not required to report on the adequacy of internal financial controls.
2. There is no compulsory rotation of auditors, which can reduce costs and administrative burdens.

Compliance Ease 

A director can sign annual returns in the absence of a company secretary, further streamlining operations.

Reduced Penalties for Non-Compliance: 

This encourages small companies to focus on growth rather than worrying excessively about penalties.

These exemptions and relaxations aim to ease the compliance burden on small companies, allowing them to focus on their core business activities and growth strategies.

{{company-reg-cta}}

Characteristics of a Small Company in India

Small companies in India have distinct characteristics that set them apart from larger enterprises. Some of the key traits include:

Ownership Structure 

Typically, small companies are privately owned entities, often structured as private limited companies, partnerships, or sole proprietorships. This ownership model allows for greater control and flexibility in decision-making but limits access to larger capital investments.

Simplified Compliance 

One of the key advantages of being classified as a small company is the reduced compliance burden. They benefit from exemptions, such as not needing to prepare cash flow statements, simplified annual filings, and fewer requirements for board meetings—only two are mandated per year. These measures significantly alleviate administrative pressures, allowing owners to focus on core business activities.

Auditing Requirements 

Small companies face less stringent auditing requirements. For instance, they are not obligated to rotate auditors or report on the adequacy of internal financial controls, which reduces costs and simplifies financial oversight.

Limited Resources and Workforce

Small companies generally operate with limited resources and a smaller workforce. They often employ fewer staff members, sometimes relying on a single individual or a small team to manage operations. This can lead to agility in decision-making but may also pose challenges in scaling operations or managing increased demand.

Restricted Market Reach

The market reach of small companies is typically confined to local or regional areas. They often serve niche markets or specific community needs, such as convenience stores in rural areas. This limitation can hinder growth opportunities compared to larger firms with broader market access.

How to Register a Small Company as per the Companies Act 2013?

To register a business online as a small company under the Companies Act 2013, follow these steps:

1. Obtain Digital Signature Certificates (DSCs) for all proposed directors and subscribers
2. Reserve the company name by submitting Part-A of the SPICe+ form
3. File Part-B of the SPICe+ form along with required documents (Memorandum of Association (MOA), Articles of Association (AOA), Professional Declaration, Affidavits, Identity and Address Proofs, and Correspondence Address)
4. Pay prescribed fees and stamp duty for the SPICe+ form, MOA, and AOA
5. Obtain the Certificate of Incorporation from the Registrar of Companies (ROC) upon successful review of submitted documents

Matters to be included in the Board's Report for small companies:

• The web address for the Annual Return (if available)
• Number of Board meetings held during the year
• Directors' Responsibility Statement as per Section 134(5)
• Details of any frauds reported by the auditor under Section 143(12), except those reportable to the Central Government
• Explanations or comments on any qualifications, reservations, or adverse remarks in the auditor's report
• Summary of the company's current affairs and business overview
• Financial summary or highlights
• Material changes in the nature of the business after the financial year-end and their impact on the company's financial position
• Changes in directorship during the year
• Significant legal or regulatory orders affecting the company's going concern status or future operations

Synopsis of MCA Notification on Companies (Specification of Definition details) Amendment Rules 2022

The MCA has issued the Companies (Specification of Definition details) Amendment Rules, 2022, effective from 15 September 2022. The key amendments include:

1. Rule 2 has been amended by substituting a new clause 2(1)(t), which specifies the revised definition of small companies.
2. The thresholds for paid-up capital and turnover have been increased in the definition of a small company under the Companies Act 2013.

These amendments aim to provide relief to a larger number of businesses by classifying them as small companies and offering them various benefits and exemptions under the Companies Act 2013.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Depreciation?

Depreciation is the systematic allocation of an asset's cost throughout its productive lifespan. It acknowledges that assets contribute to revenue generation over multiple periods and should be expensed accordingly. Without depreciation, businesses would show dramatic profit fluctuations - significant losses when purchasing assets followed by artificially inflated profits in subsequent years.

The Indian regulatory framework recognizes two distinct approaches to depreciation. The Companies Act 2013 employs a useful life methodology for financial reporting, while the Income Tax Act prescribes specific rates for tax calculation purposes.

From an accounting perspective, depreciation appears as an expense in the Profit & Loss Account, reducing reported profit. Simultaneously, accumulated depreciation diminishes the asset's book value on the Balance Sheet, reflecting its decreasing value over time.

Several factors influence depreciation calculations, including the asset's original cost, estimated useful life, and expected residual value. Different methods may be applied based on regulatory requirements and business preferences.

Understanding depreciation is critical for businesses as it significantly impacts financial statements, tax liabilities, and strategic decision-making. The varying approaches between the Companies Act 2013 and Income Tax Act create temporary differences that require reconciliation during tax calculations.

The Purpose of Depreciation

Depreciation goes beyond tracking asset wear and tear, it aligns asset costs with the revenue they help generate, ensuring accurate financial reporting through the matching principle.

Without it, businesses would expense the full asset cost upfront, causing erratic profit figures, losses during purchase years and inflated gains afterward.

Key purposes of depreciation:

• Cost Allocation: Spreads asset cost over its useful life
  
• Profit Measurement: Matches expenses with related income
  
• Tax Efficiency: Enables tax deductions under the Income Tax Act
  
• Asset Replacement: Aids in planning for future replacements
  
• Financial Stability: Smooths profit reporting over time
  

In India, depreciation is a non-cash expense. Companies Act rates differ from Income Tax Act rates, leading to temporary timing differences reconciled through deferred tax accounting. Both systems aim to fairly allocate asset costs over time.

Importance of Depreciation

Depreciation serves as a cornerstone of sound financial management, with implications reaching far beyond routine accounting entries. The strategic implementation of depreciation practices significantly impacts business operations across multiple dimensions.

Why is depreciation so critical for businesses?

Financial statements without proper depreciation would present a severely distorted view of company performance. Consider purchasing a ₹50 lakh manufacturing machine—expensing this entire amount immediately would dramatically reduce that period's profit. Subsequently, future periods would show artificially inflated profits as the machine generates revenue without corresponding expenses. This creates misleading financial trends that can confuse investors and stakeholders about the company's true financial health.

The depreciation methodology varies substantially between regulatory frameworks. A company typically uses straight-line depreciation following Schedule II of the Companies Act for financial reporting, while simultaneously applying the Written Down Value method at Income Tax Act rates for tax purposes. This dual approach helps optimize both financial reporting accuracy and tax efficiency.

Depreciation impacts businesses in five critical ways:

1. Financial Stability - Prevents dramatic profit fluctuations by distributing asset costs over multiple periods
   
2. Resource Planning - Helps accumulate funds for eventual asset replacement
   
3. Investor Confidence - Provides more realistic performance metrics for investment decisions
   
4. Tax Planning - Creates opportunities for tax-efficient asset management
   
5. Business Valuation - Affects key metrics used in determining company worth
   

For Indian businesses, understanding depreciation rates under both regulatory frameworks is essential. The Income Tax Act allows depreciation as a deduction when calculating income under "Income from Business and Profession," directly affecting taxable income. Meanwhile, the Companies Act 2013 focuses on representing the true economic consumption of asset value.

Without proper depreciation accounting, businesses would struggle to present an accurate representation of their financial reality. The systematic allocation of asset costs ensures financial statements reflect a company's true economic position, providing stakeholders with reliable information for decision-making.

{{company-reg-cta}}

Types of Depreciable Assets

Identifying qualified assets is the essential first step for businesses looking to claim depreciation benefits. Under both the Companies Act and Income Tax Act, depreciable assets fall into two primary categories that form the foundation of depreciation calculations.

Tangible Assets

These physical assets constitute the backbone of most business operations and include:

• Buildings: This category includes residential structures with a 5% depreciation rate, hotels and boarding houses at 10%, and temporary wooden structures at a higher 40% rate
  
• Furniture and Fittings: All furniture including electrical installations qualify for a 10% depreciation rate
  
• Plant and Machinery: This diverse category encompasses motor vehicles (15% rate), while computers and software receive an accelerated 40% rate
  
• Vehicles: Commercial vehicles like taxis, buses, and lorries used in hire businesses attract a 30% depreciation rate
  
• Books: Professional annual publications qualify for 100% depreciation, while non-annual publications receive 60%
  

Intangible Assets

Though lacking physical form, these assets hold significant business value and generally receive a uniform 25% depreciation rate:

• Franchises
  
• Trademarks
  
• Patents
  
• Licenses
  
• Copyrights
  
• Know-how
  
• Other similar business or commercial rights
  

The Block of Assets Concept

The Income Tax Act introduces a unique "Block of Assets" approach, where assets with similar characteristics are grouped together. Initially, tangible assets are categorized as building, machinery, plant, or furniture. For assets to form a block, they must attract identical depreciation rates.

Once assets are grouped into a block, they lose their individual identity for depreciation purposes. This approach significantly simplifies tax compliance by eliminating the need to track numerous individual assets.

Qualification Requirements

For assets to qualify for depreciation claims, they must meet two essential conditions:

1. Ownership: The assets must be owned by the assessee, either wholly or partly
   
2. Business Usage: The assets must be used for business or professional purposes
   

Year-round usage isn't mandatory—even seasonal utilization qualifies for appropriate depreciation benefits. This provision acknowledges the reality of businesses with cyclical operations.

Companies typically classify their assets based on nature, useful life, and applicable depreciation rates as prescribed in the respective acts, ensuring proper accounting and taxation treatment.

What is Written Down Value or WDV Asset?

Written Down Value (WDV) serves as the foundation for depreciation calculations under the Income Tax Act. Rather than using the original cost, depreciation is computed on the remaining value of an asset or block of assets after deducting previous depreciation claims.

How is WDV Calculated?

WDV essentially represents an asset's cost minus all accumulated depreciation claimed until date. For tax purposes, this calculation becomes particularly important since depreciation applies to the WDV of entire asset blocks rather than individual items.

The formula for determining WDV can be expressed as:

Opening WDV of block + Cost of new assets purchased during the year - Money received from assets sold = Closing value of block before depreciation

After determining this value, you apply the applicable depreciation rate to arrive at the final WDV. Consider this practical example:

A machinery block with 15% depreciation rate has an opening value of ₹5,00,000. New equipment worth ₹40,000 was purchased and used for less than 180 days. The depreciation calculation would be:

(₹5,00,000 × 15%) + (₹40,000 × 15% × 1/2) = ₹75,000 + ₹3,000 = ₹78,000

The closing WDV after depreciation would therefore be ₹4,62,000.

Once assets are grouped into a block, they lose their individual identity for depreciation purposes. This unified approach significantly simplifies tax compliance for businesses.

WDV vs. Straight-Line Method

The WDV method typically results in higher depreciation charges during earlier years, which gradually decrease over time. This contrasts with the Straight-Line Method where depreciation remains constant throughout an asset's lifetime.

While the Income Tax Act mandates the WDV method for most assets (with exceptions for power generating units), the Companies Act 2013 offers businesses flexibility to choose between Straight-Line, WDV, or Unit of Production methods based on asset types and business requirements.

The WDV approach better reflects economic reality, as assets generally lose more value during their initial years of use and experience diminishing depreciation as they age.

What are the Conditions for Claiming Depreciation

The Income Tax Act establishes specific conditions that businesses must satisfy before claiming depreciation benefits. These requirements ensure proper tax treatment while preventing misuse of depreciation provisions.

Ownership Requirement

Ownership stands as the fundamental condition for claiming depreciation. The assessee must own the asset, either wholly or partly, to qualify for depreciation benefits. However, several notable exceptions exist:

• When an assessee constructs a building on leased land, depreciation can be claimed on the structure despite not owning the land
  
• In mortgage situations where assets are built on mortgaged property, depreciation remains available
  
• For finance lease arrangements, lessees can claim depreciation despite not being legal owners
  

Conversely, in short-term hire-purchase arrangements, depreciation claims aren't permitted as ownership hasn't effectively transferred.

Business Purpose Utilization

Assets must be employed for business or professional purposes to qualify for depreciation. This doesn't mean the asset requires year-round usage - even seasonal factories with limited operational periods qualify for full depreciation benefits.

When assets serve dual purposes (both business and personal), depreciation is allowed proportionately based on business usage. For example, if a vehicle is used 70% for business and 30% for personal purposes, depreciation can be claimed on 70% of its value.

Additional Key Conditions

• Asset Sale Restriction: If an asset is sold, discarded, or damaged in the same year it was purchased, the assessee cannot claim depreciation on it
  
• Co-ownership Provisions: When multiple parties co-own an asset, each co-owner may claim depreciation based on their ownership share
  
• Mandatory Application: Depreciation is compulsory under the Income Tax Act - from Assessment Year 2002-03, it's deemed allowed even if not explicitly claimed in financial statements
  

Keep in mind that for taxpayers using presumptive taxation schemes, the deemed profit is considered to already include depreciation. The prescribed rates under the Income Tax Act must be followed regardless of different rates used in financial statements under the Companies Act.

The Written Down Value must be carried forward after reducing the depreciation amount, ensuring proper asset valuation in subsequent years.

Different Methods of Depreciation Calculation

Businesses employ several methodologies to calculate depreciation on assets, with approaches varying based on regulatory requirements. The Companies Act and Income Tax Act prescribe different methods, each serving distinct financial and tax objectives.

What are the Key Depreciation Methods under Companies Act?

The depreciation landscape in India is shaped by specific methods allowed under different regulatory frameworks:

Under Companies Act 1956 (Based on Specified Rates):

• Straight Line Method
  
• Written Down Value Method
  

Under Companies Act 2013 (Based on Useful Life):

• Straight Line Method
  
• Written Down Value Method
  
• Unit of Production Method
  

Under Income Tax Act 1961 (Based on Specified Rates):

• Written Down Value Method (Block-wise) - Primary method
  
• Straight Line Method (exclusively for Power Generating Units)
  

How Do These Methods Work?

Straight Line Method (SLM) distributes depreciation equally throughout an asset's useful life. This straightforward approach uses the formula:

Rate of Depreciation = [(Original Cost – Residual Value) / Useful Life] × 100

The annual depreciation amount equals: Depreciation = Original Cost × Rate of Depreciation

Written Down Value Method (WDV) calculates depreciation on the reducing balance of an asset. This method applies a fixed percentage to the asset's remaining value after previous depreciation. Unlike SLM, WDV results in higher depreciation in earlier years, gradually decreasing over time.

Unit of Production Method, introduced in Companies Act 2013, links depreciation to actual usage rather than time. This method proves particularly beneficial for assets whose value diminishes based on production output rather than mere passage of time.

Throughout the depreciation lifecycle, businesses must reconcile differences between accounting and tax treatments. A company might simultaneously apply SLM for financial reporting (Companies Act) and WDV for tax purposes (Income Tax Act), creating temporary differences that require deferred tax adjustments.

These methodological differences lead to varied depreciation amounts and significantly impact financial ratios, tax liabilities, and overall business valuation. The selection of depreciation method therefore represents a strategic financial decision rather than merely an accounting choice.

{{company-reg-cta}}

Impact of Depreciation Method

The selection of depreciation methods significantly influences a business's financial statements and tax obligations. The difference between methods prescribed under the Companies Act versus the Income Tax Act creates varying depreciation amounts for identical assets.

When businesses apply the Straight-Line Method under Companies Act for financial reporting while simultaneously using the Written Down Value Method for tax calculations, timing differences naturally emerge. These differences necessitate deferred tax accounting to ensure financial statements accurately reflect future tax implications.

Here's a practical example demonstrating depreciation calculation under the Income Tax Act:

This calculation affects financial reporting significantly. Under Accounting Standard-22 (AS-22) or IND AS 12, companies must account for temporary differences between accounting and tax depreciation. Consider an asset costing ₹150 with a carrying amount of ₹100 but a tax base of ₹60 (after ₹90 in tax depreciation). This creates a temporary difference of ₹40.

With a 25% tax rate, the company must recognize a deferred tax liability of ₹10 (₹40×25%) in financial statements, representing future taxes payable when recovering the asset's carrying amount.

Businesses must carefully evaluate which depreciation method to adopt, as it impacts:

• Reported profits in financial statements
  
• Timing of tax payments
  
• Cash flow planning
  
• Financial ratios used for performance evaluation
  

The differences in depreciation calculation extend beyond mere accounting technicalities—they have substantial financial implications requiring strategic consideration by business management.

Depreciation Rates under Companies & Income Tax Act

Amount of Depreciation Allowed

The Income Tax Act establishes specific parameters for calculating permissible depreciation amounts. The framework includes clearly defined methods and rates that businesses must follow when preparing tax returns. The Written Down Value (WDV) method serves as the mandated approach for most businesses, with precise rates outlined in Appendix 1 of the Act.

Special Provisions for Power Generation Businesses

Power generation businesses enjoy unique flexibility within the tax framework. These undertakings can select either the WDV method or the Straight-Line method when claiming depreciation. This choice offers valuable tax planning opportunities but must be exercised before the tax return's due date.

Corporate Restructuring Scenarios

When businesses undergo amalgamation or demerger, depreciation calculations require special attention. The total depreciation allowance is distributed between the participating companies based on a specific formula. This calculation follows an interesting approach - it assumes the restructuring never occurred, with the amount apportioned according to the number of days each entity utilized the assets.

Finance Lease Considerations

Finance lease arrangements present another notable exception to standard ownership requirements. When a lessee capitalizes assets in accordance with Accounting Standard-19 on Leases, they can claim depreciation despite not being the legal owner. This provision recognizes the economic reality that lessees effectively exercise ownership rights in such arrangements.

Impact of Acquisition Timing

The timing of asset purchases significantly affects allowable depreciation. Assets used for fewer than 180 days in a financial year qualify for only half the applicable rate, as shown below:

Dual Calculation Approaches

Companies typically maintain separate depreciation calculations for financial reporting versus tax purposes. This dual approach stems from the differing objectives between regulatory frameworks. The Companies Act focuses on representing the true economic consumption of asset value, providing an accurate financial picture. In contrast, the Income Tax Act aims to standardize tax deductions across businesses, creating a uniform system for taxation purposes.

Understanding these provisions helps businesses maximize legitimate tax benefits while maintaining compliance with regulatory requirements.

Depreciation Rates for FY 2025-26 for Most Commonly Used Assets

The Income Tax Act provides a structured framework of depreciation rates for FY 2025-26 that businesses must apply when calculating their tax liabilities. These rates serve as a critical reference point for financial planning and tax compliance.

The depreciation rate chart is organized into two main sections: Part A for Tangible Assets and Part B for Intangible Assets. Each asset category has been assigned specific rates based on their nature, expected useful life, and wear and tear patterns.

Buildings fall into several sub-categories with varying rates:

• Residential structures - 5% depreciation rate
  
• Commercial buildings and hotels - 10% depreciation rate
  
• Temporary wooden structures - 40% depreciation rate (reflecting their shorter lifespan)
  

Furniture and fittings including electrical fixtures attract a standard 10% depreciation rate across all types and usage patterns.

Plant and machinery encompasses a diverse range of assets with differentiated rates:

• Standard machinery - 15% depreciation rate
  
• Computers and software - 40% depreciation rate
• Motor vehicles for business use - 15% depreciation rate
  
• Commercial vehicles used in hiring businesses - 30% depreciation rate
  

Books owned by professionals receive specialized treatment under the tax code:

• Annual publications - 100% write-off
  
• Non-annual professional books - 60% depreciation rate
• Lending library books - 100% depreciation rate
  

Intangible assets such as franchises, trademarks, patents, licenses, and copyrights uniformly qualify for a 25% depreciation rate.

The timing of asset acquisition plays a significant role in depreciation calculations. Assets used for less than 180 days in a financial year qualify for only half the applicable rate. For example, a car worth ₹3,00,000 purchased in the latter half of the fiscal year would receive depreciation of ₹22,500 (calculated as ₹3,00,000 × 15% × ½).

Businesses must carefully apply these prescribed rates based on accurate asset classification and usage period. Proper implementation ensures both tax compliance and optimization of legitimate deductions, ultimately affecting the company's financial position and tax liability.

Depreciation Rates as Per the Income Tax Act

The Income Tax Act establishes a structured classification system for depreciable assets with specific rates assigned to each category. These prescribed rates serve as the foundation for tax calculations across businesses in India and fall into two distinct sections.

Part A: Tangible Assets This section covers physical assets used in business operations:

Part B: Intangible Assets For intellectual property and similar business rights, the Income Tax Act maintains a consistent approach:

Intangible assets including franchises, trademarks, patents, licenses, and copyrights all qualify for a uniform 25% depreciation rate.

Businesses must classify their assets according to this framework when calculating taxable income. The structure creates standardization across industries while acknowledging the varying lifespans of different asset types.

Timing plays a crucial role in depreciation calculations under the Income Tax Act. Assets used for less than 180 days in a financial year receive only half the applicable rate. This provision ensures tax treatment reflects actual asset utilization periods.

While the Companies Act 2013 focuses on the useful life approach for depreciation, the Income Tax Act provides these fixed rates to create uniformity in tax treatment. This fundamental difference often results in separate depreciation amounts between financial reporting and tax calculations, requiring businesses to maintain dual record systems.

The block-of-assets concept further simplifies tax depreciation by grouping similar assets together and treating them as a single entity. This approach streamlines compliance while providing standardized treatment across industries.

Rate of Depreciation under the Companies Act 2013

The Companies Act 2013 represents a significant paradigm shift in how businesses approach depreciation for financial reporting. Unlike its predecessor, this Act adopts a useful life approach rather than relying on fixed percentage rates. This fundamental change focuses on reflecting the true economic consumption of asset value over time, creating a more accurate financial representation.

How does Schedule II impact depreciation calculations?

Schedule II of the Companies Act 2013 provides a comprehensive reference chart detailing useful lives for various asset categories. This schedule serves as a guideline for determining appropriate depreciation periods, representing a significant departure from the percentage-based approach of the 1956 Act.

The formula for calculating depreciation typically follows: Rate of Depreciation = [(Original Cost – Residual Value) / Useful Life] × 100

What are the financial reporting implications?

The useful life approach often yields different depreciation amounts compared to tax calculations under the Income Tax Act. These variations create temporary differences that require deferred tax accounting treatments. Consequently, most businesses maintain separate depreciation records, one for financial reporting compliance and another for tax purposes.

Companies must disclose their chosen depreciation methods, useful life assumptions, and reconciliation of differences between tax and accounting depreciation in the notes to financial statements. This transparency helps stakeholders assess the true economic value of company assets and understand management's capital allocation decisions.

Business leaders should carefully evaluate their asset portfolios to determine appropriate useful lives and select depreciation methods that best represent economic reality while complying with statutory requirements. This thoughtful approach ensures financial statements accurately reflect the company's financial position and performance.

Frequently Asked Questions

Closure of LLP - Overview

The Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) closure process is a significant decision that can arise from various circumstances. Whether driven by voluntary factors, such as a mutual decision by the partners to discontinue operations, or involuntary factors, like non-compliance with statutory requirements, understanding the reasons and methods of closure is crucial.

The decision to close an LLP often stems from the following reasons:

1. Voluntary Closure:
   Partners may mutually agree to cease operations due to business inactivity, an unprofitable venture, or a strategic shift in focus. This proactive decision is usually taken when all stakeholders conclude that continuing operations no longer align with their goals.
2. Involuntary Closure:
   Sometimes, an LLP faces closure due to external circumstances such as non-compliance with legal or regulatory obligations, accumulation of penalties, or other statutory violations. In such cases, authorities may initiate the process of striking off the LLP from the official records.

Method or Procedure of Closing an LLP

Closing a Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) in India can be carried out through two primary methods: Voluntary Winding Up and Striking Off. Each method has its unique set of requirements, advantages, and limitations. Choosing the right approach depends on the LLP’s operational and financial status. Let’s look into the details of these two LLP closing procedures:

1. Voluntary Winding Up

Voluntary winding up is a process initiated by the partners when they collectively decide to dissolve the LLP. This method is typically chosen when the partners agree to cease operations due to inactivity, unprofitability, or a strategic decision to exit.

Advantages of Voluntary Winding Up:

• Controlled and Planned Process
• Avoids Penalties for Non-Compliance

Disadvantages of Voluntary Winding Up:

• Time-Consuming
• Settlement of Liabilities Required

2. Striking Off

Striking off is a simpler and faster method for closing an LLP. It is suitable for LLPs that have been inactive for a significant period and have no outstanding liabilities. This process involves applying to the RoC to remove the LLP’s name from the register.

Advantages of Striking Off:

• Simplified and Less Expensive
• Suitable for Dormant LLPs

Disadvantages of Striking Off:

• Not Applicable for LLPs with Liabilities
• Limited Scope for Active LLPs

Step-by-Step Procedure to Close an LLP

A brief overview of the process for closure of LLP in India:

1. Passing a Resolution for Winding Up

The first step is for the partners to pass a resolution for voluntary winding up. A majority of partners must agree, and the resolution must be filed with the ROC within 30 days.

2. Appointing a Liquidator

The partners must appoint a liquidator to oversee the winding-up process. The liquidator’s role includes realising the LLP’s assets and settling its liabilities.

3. Realising Assets and Paying Off Liabilities

The liquidator identifies and sells the LLP’s assets to clear all outstanding liabilities. Surplus funds, if any, are distributed among the partners.

4. Filing the Necessary Forms with the ROC

The LLP must file forms such as Form 24 and other requisite filings with the ROC to notify the authorities about the closure.

5. Obtaining the Final Order of Dissolution

After reviewing all filings and confirming the settlement of liabilities, the ROC issues a final order of dissolution, formally closing the LLP.

Filing LLP Form 24: Step-by-Step Process

Closing a Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) in India requires filing LLP Form 24 with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA). Below is a simplified step-by-step process to help you navigate this procedure:

1. Cease Business Operations

Before applying for closure, ensure that the LLP has either never commenced business or has stopped all commercial activities. If your LLP is still active, suspend all operations before proceeding.

2. Settle Liabilities and Close Bank Accounts

LLP Form 24 can only be filed if the LLP has no outstanding creditors and all bank accounts are closed. Obtain a closure letter from the bank as proof.

3. Draft Partner Affidavits

All designated partners must prepare an affidavit declaring:

• The LLP has ceased operations from a specific date or never started.
• The LLP has no liabilities, and partners agree to indemnify any future claims.

4. Prepare Supporting Documents

Attach the following documents to LLP Form 24:

• Copy of the latest Income Tax Return (if filed). If no returns were filed, this is not required for non-operational LLPs.
• A statement of accounts showing nil assets and liabilities, certified by a Chartered Accountant, dated no more than 30 days before filing.

5. Resolve Pending Filings

Ensure that:

• The LLP Agreement is filed, if not already done.
• Any overdue Form 8 and Form 11 are submitted up to the date of cessation of business.

6. File LLP Form 24 with MCA

Submit the completed LLP Form 24 with all attachments to the MCA. Once reviewed, a notice of striking off will be published on the MCA website if no objections are raised.

Documents Required to Close the LLP

Here is a list of LLP closure documents required during the process:

• Board Resolution for Winding Up: Document signed by all partners approving the winding-up process.
• Liquidator’s Consent: Written consent from the appointed liquidator.
• No-Objection Certificate from Creditors: If applicable, creditors must provide a no-objection certificate.
• Final Accounts and Balance Sheet: Statement of accounts showing all liabilities cleared.
• Tax Clearance Certificates: Certificate from the tax authorities confirming no pending dues.

 Conditions for LLP Closure

Certain conditions must be met before initiating the LLP closure process:

• Settlement of Debts and Liabilities: All outstanding debts and liabilities must be cleared.
• Statutory Filings: All statutory filings and compliance requirements must be up-to-date.
• Approvals: Necessary approvals from all partners and creditors (if applicable) must be obtained.

Advantages and Disadvantages of LLP

Like any business entity, an LLP has its own advantages and disadvantages that should be carefully considered before choosing this structure.

Advantages of an LLP

1. Limited Liability: The liability of partners is limited to their agreed contribution to the business, protecting personal assets in case of business debts or losses.
2. Separate Legal Entity: An LLP is a separate legal entity from its partners, meaning it can own assets, enter into contracts, and sue or be sued independently.
3. Flexibility in Management: There is no strict separation between ownership and management, allowing partners to manage the business as per their agreement.
4. No Minimum Capital Requirement: Unlike private limited companies, LLPs do not have a minimum capital requirement, making them more accessible to small businesses and startups.
5. Ease of Compliance: LLPs have fewer compliance requirements compared to companies, such as no mandatory board meetings or annual general meetings.
6. Unlimited Number of Partners: An LLP can have any number of partners, offering greater flexibility in expanding ownership.
7. Low Registration Cost: Setting up an LLP is more affordable than incorporating a private limited company.

Disadvantages of an LLP

1. Limited Recognition: LLPs are not as widely recognised as private limited companies, which may affect investor confidence or business collaborations.
2. Restrictions on Fundraising: LLPs cannot raise funds through equity, making them less suitable for businesses looking to attract venture capital or private equity investment.
3. Limited Scope for Public Trust: LLPs are not listed on stock exchanges, so they may lack the transparency that comes with publicly traded companies, leading to lower public trust.
4. Difficulty in Expansion: LLPs are not ideal for businesses aiming for rapid scalability, as the inability to issue shares limits their access to growth capital.

An LLP is an excellent choice for small businesses, professionals, and startups looking for a flexible, cost-effective business structure with limited liability. However, it may not be suitable for companies that require significant funding or aspire to scale rapidly. 

Frequently Asked Questions