The SAMRIDH Scheme

Defining Oppression and Mismanagement

The Companies Act, 2013, does not explicitly define oppression and mismanagement. Instead, their meanings have evolved through judicial interpretations and case law.

In simple terms:

• Oppression involves burdensome, harsh, or wrongful conduct toward minority shareholders. It typically refers to situations where the majority shareholders abuse their power to harm the minority's rights or interests.
  
  
• Mismanagement refers to gross mismanagement of company affairs, which could lead to financial loss or harm to the company’s reputation or operations. It often involves negligence, fraud, or actions taken in bad faith by those in control.

Legal Remedies under Sections 241–246

Sections 241 to 246 of the Companies Act, 2013 empower company members to approach the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) if they believe the company’s affairs are being conducted in a manner that amounts to oppression or mismanagement.

If the tribunal is satisfied, it can order remedies such as:

• Regulation of the company’s future conduct
• Removal of directors
• Termination, modification, or setting aside of certain agreements
• Recovery of misappropriated funds
• Preventive actions to safeguard the company’s interests

A Detailed Explanation of Section 241

Section 241 of the Companies Act, 2013 is the core provision that allows members to seek relief from oppression and mismanagement.

Section 241 exists to protect minority shareholders and the company itself from conduct that threatens their interests. It ensures that no shareholder or director misuses their powers to the detriment of others or the company.

Under Section 241, a member can apply to the NCLT if:

• The company’s affairs are being conducted in a manner oppressive to any member(s).
• There has been mismanagement that threatens to cause serious prejudice to the interests of the company, members, or the public.

How can an Application be made under Section 241?

Filing an application under Section 241 involves a specific legal process:

Who Can Apply?

Eligible members include:

• Shareholders holding at least 10% of the company’s issued share capital
• In companies without share capital, at least 1/5th of the total number of members
  In certain cases, members may request NCLT permission to file even if they do not meet the above thresholds (especially where the majority is acting in bad faith).

Grounds for Filing

The application must clearly describe:

• Acts of oppression (specific conduct harming member rights)
• Acts of mismanagement (negligence, fraud, misconduct, etc.)
• Resulting harm to the company or its members

Documentation Required

• Petition/application under Section 241
• Evidence of shareholding or membership eligibility
• Documentary proof of oppressive/mismanaged conduct
• Affidavit verifying the facts
• Court fees as prescribed

Where to File?

Applications must be filed with the relevant bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) having jurisdiction over the company’s registered office.

{{company-reg-cta}}

Who Can File an Application under Section 241 of the Companies Act, 2013?

Eligibility to file under Section 241 depends on the applicant’s status and shareholding:

In addition, the Central Government can also apply under Section 241(2) if it believes the affairs of the company are conducted in a manner prejudicial to public interest.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is Capital Redemption Reserve?

The Capital Redemption Reserve (CRR) is a special reserve that a company must create when it redeems (buys back) its preference shares using its profits. As per corporate law, companies must transfer an amount equal to the nominal value of redeemed preference shares to the CRR to prevent capital reduction and maintain financial integrity.

When Is Capital Redemption Reserve Used?

CRR is utilised in various financial scenarios to maintain corporate stability, including:

• Issuing bonus shares: CRR can be used to issue fully paid bonus shares to shareholders.
  
• Funding share redemption: Ensures funds are available for preference share redemption.
  
• Capital reconstruction: Helps restructure a company’s capital without impacting free reserves.
  
• Balancing capital losses: Used in cases where capital losses need adjustment.
  
• Source for share buybacks: Required when companies buy back shares using free reserves.
  

Redemption Of Preference Capital

The redemption of preference shares is subject to the following regulations:

• Must be permitted in the Articles of Association.
  
• Redeemable within 20 years of issue.
  
• Methods of redemption:
  
  • Using Distributable Profits: Requires CRR creation.
    
  • Issuing Fresh Shares: CRR creation is not required if new capital is issued.
    
• Shareholder Approval (75%): Required for further preference share issues.
  
• Premium Payment: This can be funded from company profits or the securities premium account.
  

Modes of Redemption

The three primary modes of redemption are:

1. Using Distributable Profits: CRR creation is mandatory, equal to the nominal value of redeemed shares.
   
2. Issuing Fresh Capital: If a company issues fresh capital equal to the redemption amount, CRR creation is not required.
   
3. Combination of Both: CRR is required only for the portion funded through distributable profits.
   

Modes of Redemption of Preference Shares

Companies can redeem (buy back) preference shares using one of the following methods:

1. Using Distributable Profits
   The company uses its retained earnings or other profits to redeem the shares. In this case, it must create a Capital Redemption Reserve (CRR) equal to the nominal value of the redeemed shares to maintain financial stability.
   
2. Issuing Fresh Capital
   The company raises funds by issuing new shares to replace the redeemed preference shares. Since this method does not reduce capital, creating a CRR is not required.
   
3. Combination of Both
   A company may use both profits and fresh capital for redemption. CRR is required only for the portion funded through distributable profits, while the part covered by fresh capital does not require CRR.

{{company-reg-cta}}

Calculation and Accounting Entries For Capital Redemption Reserve

Calculation of CRR

CRR = Nominal Value of Redeemed Preference Shares (if using distributable profits)

Journal Entries

Application of Capital Redemption Reserve

• CRR can only be used for issuing fully paid bonus shares.
  
• CRR cannot be used for dividend distribution.
  
• CRR must exclude unrealised gains and self-generated intangible assets before determining free reserves.
  
• Classified as a statutory reserve, separate from revenue reserves.
  

Companies Act and Capital Redemption Reserve

• Section 55: Companies redeeming preference shares from profits must transfer an equivalent amount to CRR.
  
• Section 69: Companies buying back shares using free reserves or securities premiums must transfer an amount equal to the face value of bought-back shares to CRR.
  

Difference Between Capital Redemption Reserve and Other Reserves

Tax Benefits For Capital Redemption Reserve

Under Section 36(1)(viii) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, specified entities can claim a tax deduction on contributions to a Special Reserve, reducing their taxable income. The deduction is capped at 20% of profits from eligible business activities before applying this clause. However, any future withdrawal from the reserve is treated as taxable income in the year of withdrawal.

Importance Of Capital Redemption Reserve

• Maintains Financial Stability: Prevents a reduction in share capital.
  
• Protects Shareholders’ Interests: Ensures capital is available for redemption.
  
• Supports Capital Restructuring: Used in financial restructuring strategies.
  
• Ensures Legal Compliance: Meets regulatory requirements under the Companies Act.
  
• Enhances Investor Confidence: Used for issuing bonus shares, benefiting shareholders.
  

Final Thoughts

The Capital Redemption Reserve (CRR) plays a vital role in corporate finance by ensuring companies retain sufficient funds while redeeming preference shares. As a statutory reserve, it helps maintain financial stability, protects creditors' interests, and complies with legal requirements.

While it cannot be used freely like other reserves, its role in issuing fully paid bonus shares makes it a strategic asset for companies looking to optimise their financial position.

Frequently Asked Questions

Importance of a Digital Signature Certificate

The importance of a Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) lies in its ability to provide strong authentication, integrity, and proper encryptions in digital transactions and communications.

Here are several key reasons why DSCs are important and why you should apply for one as a founder:

1. Authentication

• DSCs verify the identity of individuals, organizations, or devices involved in digital transactions, ensuring that the sender is who they claim to be.

2. Integrity

• Digital signatures created using DSCs ensure the integrity of electronic documents or messages by detecting any unauthorized changes or tampering.

3. Security

• DSCs use strong cryptographic techniques to protect sensitive information and prevent unauthorized access.

4. Legal Recognition

• In India, many industries and regulatory frameworks require the use of DSCs for specific types of transactions or communications to comply with security and privacy regulations.

5. Government Services

• DSCs play an important role in the company registration process irrespective of the company type. Accessing government services, filing tax returns, or participating in e-tendering processes require digital signatures for authentication and authorization.

6. Efficiency

• DSCs streamline digital workflows by enabling secure and paperless transactions without the physical presence.

Overall, DSCs offer numerous benefits, including enhanced security, legal validity, efficiency, and cost savings, making them indispensable for digital transactions and communications

Different Classes of Digital Signature Certificates (DSCs)

Certifying authorities issue 3 types of DSCs to accommodate various needs and purposes.The type of applicant and the intended use of the Digital Signature Certificate determine the specific kind of DSC that should be sought based on the requirements.

Class 1 DSC:

• These certificates are issued for individuals or private users and are primarily used for email communication and basic transactions.
• Verification requirements are minimal, typically involving email validation or verification of basic personal information.

Class 2 DSC:

• Class 2 certificates are used for both individual and organizational purposes and offer a higher level of security and trust compared to Class 1.
• To obtain a Class 2 DSC, the applicant's identity is verified against a trusted government-issued identity document, such as a passport or driver's license.

Class 3 DSC:

• Class 3 certificates provide the highest level of security and are typically used for online transactions involving high-value financial transactions, e-commerce, and government applications.
• The verification process for Class 3 DSCs involves rigorous identity verification procedures, including in-person verification and submission of supporting documents.

Certifying Authorities in India

Certifying Agencies are designated by the office of the Controller of Certification Agencies (CCA) in accordance with the provisions of the IT Act, 2000. Currently, there are eight Certification Agencies authorized by the CCA to issue Digital Signature Certificates (DSCs).

Format of a Digital Signature Certificate

A DSC typically contains the following components:

1. Public Key

• A cryptographic key that is made publicly available and used to verify digital signatures created by the corresponding private key.

2. Private Key

• A secret key that is securely held by the owner and used to create digital signatures for documents or messages.

3. Certificate Information

• Details about the certificate, including the issuer (Certifying Authority), the validity period, a unique identifier, the subject (owner), and the digital signature of the CA to confirm its authenticity.

4. Digital Signature

• A unique digital signature generated using the private key of the certificate, which can be verified using the corresponding public key.

The format of a Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) can vary depending on the issuing Certificate Authority (CA) and the type and class of the certificate.

Documents required for obtaining a Digital Signature Certificate

The documents required for obtaining a Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) include:

• Proof of Identity: Copy of any one of the following government-issued identity documents attested by a Gazetted officer:
  • Passport
  • Aadhaar Card
  • PAN Card
  • Voter ID Card
• Proof of Address: Copy of any one of the following documents showing the applicant's residential address attested by a Gazetted officer:
  • Utility bill (electricity, water, gas, telephone)
  • Bank statement
  • Rent agreement
• Passport Size Photograph: Recent passport-size color photograph of the applicant.
• Self-attested Copy of PAN Card: A self-attested photocopy of the applicant's PAN Card.
• Organization Documents (if applicable):For organizations, additional documents such as the Certificate of Incorporation, Memorandum of Association (MOA), Articles of Association (AOA), or Partnership Deed may be required.

It's important to note that the specific documents required may vary depending on the type of Digital Signature Certificate (e.g., Class 1, Class 2, Class 3), the Certification Authority (CA) issuing the certificate, and the purpose for which the certificate is being obtained.

How to apply for a Digital Signature Certificate?

Razorpay Rize simplifies this process by streamlining e-filing on the MCA portal (company registration process), and as part of the package, you can acquire 2 Digital Signature Certificates for the involved directors/partners.

Note: It's necessary to obtain a Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) of either the Class 2 or Class 3 signing certificate category issued by a licensed Certifying Authority (CA) to facilitate e-filing on the MCA Portal for company registration processes.

Alternatively, you also have the option to apply for DSCs through designated certifying agencies through the following steps.

• Choose a Certifying Authority (CA) accredited by the Controller of Certification Agencies (CCA) under the provisions of the IT Act, 2000.
• Determine the type and class of DSC required based on your needs and the level of security required (e.g., Class 1, Class 2, Class 3).
• Gather the necessary documents, including proof of identity, proof of address, passport-size photograph, self-attested copy of PAN card, and any organization-related documents (if applicable).
• Obtain and fill out the DSC application form provided by the chosen Certifying Authority. Fill in the necessary details like the Class of the DSC, validity, type, applicant name and details, residential address, etc.
• Undergo the identity verification process as per the CA's requirements, which may involve in-person verification or online verification, depending on the type of DSC and the CA's policies.
• Pay the prescribed fees.
• Upon successful verification and payment, the Certifying Authority will generate a unique key pair consisting of a public key and a corresponding private key.
• Once the key pair is generated, the Certifying Authority will issue the Digital Signature Certificate.
• Install the DSC on the appropriate device or token as per the CA's instructions.

Validity of the Digital Signature Certificate

Digital Signature Certificates (DSCs) are commonly issued with either a one-year validity or a two-year validity period.

These certificates can be renewed upon expiry of the initial validity period. Renewal procedures typically involve submitting updated documentation and undergoing identity verification processes, similar to the initial application process.

Fees for the Digital Signature Certificate in India

If you’re registering your business with Razorpay Rize, DSCs are commonly included in the package regardless of the company type.

In the case of direct applications, the fees include various components, including the one-time cost of the medium (such as a USB token), the Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) issuance cost, the renewal cost after the validity period expires, and the support costs (if any).

The costs, as mentioned on the MCA website, are as follows-

Frequently Asked Questions