The SAMRIDH Scheme

What is a Public Company?

A public company, also known as a publicly traded company, is a corporation whose shares are freely bought and sold by the public on stock exchanges or over-the-counter markets. Key aspects of a public company include:

• Unlimited number of shareholders.
• Shares are publicly traded and easily transferable.
• Must issue a prospectus before offering shares to the public.
• Strict disclosure and reporting requirements.
• Ability to raise substantial capital through public markets.
• Governed by a board of directors responsible to shareholders.

Public companies must comply with stringent regulations set by securities commission like the the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI). These regulations ensure transparency, protect investor interests, and maintain market integrity.

Features of Public Limited Company

1. Free transferability of shares: Shares can be freely bought and sold on stock exchanges, providing liquidity to investors.
2. No limit on number of shareholders: There is no restriction on the maximum number of shareholders a public company can have.
3. Prospectus requirement: Public companies must issue a prospectus before offering shares to the public, disclosing key information about the company.
4. Public disclosure of financials: Public companies are required to publicly disclose their financial statements on a regular basis.
5. Strict compliance norms: Public companies are subject to stringent regulations and disclosure requirements set by governing bodies like SEBI.
6. Access to capital markets: Public companies can raise substantial funds from a large pool of investors through various securities like IPOs, FPOs, rights issues and preferential allotments.
7. Listing on stock exchanges: The shares of public companies are listed and traded on recognised stock exchanges.

What is a Private Company?

A private company, also referred to as a privately held company, is a business entity whose shares are not publicly traded. Ownership is closely held by a limited group of shareholders, such as founders, family members and private investors. Key characteristics of a private company include:

• Limited to a maximum of 200 shareholders
• Shares are privately owned and not freely transferable
• Minimal disclosure requirements and greater privacy
• Raising capital through private means like angel investors or venture capital
• Closely controlled and managed by founders and early investors

Private companies have more flexibility in their operations and decision-making as they are not subject to the same level of public scrutiny and regulatory oversight as public companies.

Features of Private Company

1. Restricted share transfer: Shares of a private company cannot be freely transferred and are subject to restrictions outlined in the company's articles of association.
2. Limited number of shareholders: Private companies can have a maximum of 200 shareholders.
3. No prospectus requirement: Private companies are not required to issue a prospectus to the public for raising funds.
4. Confidentiality of financial information: The financial statements of private companies are not publicly disclosed and remain confidential.
5. Fewer compliance requirements: Private companies have lesser compliance and regulatory filing requirements compared to public companies.
6. Flexibility in management: Private companies have greater flexibility in their management structure and decision-making processes.
7. No requirement for a statutory meeting: Private companies are not required to hold a statutory meeting or file a statutory report.

Public Company Vs Private Company

Following are the key differences between public and private companies:

The choice between operating as a public or private company depends on various factors such as the company's capital requirements, desired level of control and flexibility, willingness to disclose financial information, and long-term objectives.

Can A Public Company Convert into a Private Company and Vice Versa?

Yes, a public company can be converted into a private company and vice versa, subject to certain conditions and procedures outlined in the Companies Act 2013.

To convert a public company into a private company, the following steps need to be taken:

1. Pass a special resolution in a general meeting of the company to approve the conversion.
2. Alter the company's memorandum and articles of association to reflect the changes required for a private company.
3. File an application with the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) for approval of the conversion.
4. Obtain approval from the NCLT after considering any objections or suggestions from regulatory authorities or other stakeholders.
5. File the NCLT order approving the conversion with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) within 30 days.
6. The ROC will issue a fresh certificate of incorporation reflecting the company's status as a private company.

Similarly, a private company can be converted into a public company by following these steps:

1. Pass a special resolution in a general meeting of the company to approve the conversion.
2. Alter the company's memorandum and articles of association to comply with the requirements of a public company.
3. Increase the number of directors to the minimum required for a public company (3 directors).
4. File an application with the ROC for approval of the conversion.
5. Obtain approval from the ROC after ensuring compliance with all the necessary provisions.
6. The ROC will issue a fresh certificate of incorporation reflecting the company's status as a public company.

Conclusion

Understanding the differences between private and public companies is crucial for entrepreneurs, investors and other stakeholders. While public companies offer the advantage of access to public capital and liquidity for shareholders, they also face stricter compliance requirements and public scrutiny. On the other hand, private companies provide greater control and flexibility to shareholders but have limitations in raising capital and providing liquidity to investors.

Regardless of the choice, both private and public companies play vital roles in the economy, driving innovation, creating jobs, and contributing to overall economic growth. Understanding their distinct characteristics and the implications of each structure is essential for navigating the complex world of business and making sound decisions.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Proprietorship?

A sole proprietorship is the simplest form of business where a single individual owns, operates, and manages the business. It isn’t a separate legal entity, meaning the owner and the business are legally identical.

Key Characteristics:

• Full ownership and control: The proprietor has complete control over decisions.
• Unlimited liability: The owner is personally liable for all business debts and losses.
• No formal registration: In many cases, registration is optional, though GST or local licenses may be required.
• Limited access to capital: Raising funds from investors or banks is difficult due to a lack of legal status.
• Common use cases: Freelancers, small shop owners, consultants, and home-based businesses.

What is a Private Limited Company?

A Private Limited Company is a legally registered business entity under the Companies Act, 2013. It offers a distinct legal identity and limits the liability of shareholders to the amount invested in the company.

Key Features:

Following are the key features of a private limited company:

• Separate legal entity from its owners
• Limited liability for all shareholders
• Minimum 2 and maximum 200 shareholders
• Perpetual succession – continues to exist regardless of changes in ownership
• Preferred for scaling due to ease of raising funds, better governance, and investor confidence

‍

Ready to convert your business? Get expert assistance with company registration and start your private limited journey today.

Difference Between Proprietor and Private Limited Company

Law Governing the Conversion of Proprietorship into a Private Limited Company

The conversion is governed under:

• Companies Act, 2013 – Covers the registration and compliance of private limited companies.
  Income Tax Act, 1961 – Specifically Section 47(xiv), which allows tax-neutral transfer of assets from proprietorship to company, subject to conditions.

Key Legal Points:

• All assets and liabilities must be transferred to the company.
• The sole proprietor must hold at least 50% of the company’s shares for 5 years.
• The business must continue for a minimum of 5 years post-conversion.
• No benefit should accrue to the proprietor other than share allotment.

Benefits of Conversion from Proprietorship to Private Limited Company

Converting to a private limited company offers multiple strategic advantages:

• Limited Liability: Personal assets of owners are protected from business debts.
• Increased Credibility: Appears more professional to clients, vendors, and investors.
• Access to Funding: Equity funding becomes possible through share issuance.
• Separate Legal Identity: Contracts and property can be in the company’s name.
• Tax Benefits: Eligible for lower corporate tax rates and more deductions.
• Ownership Transfer: Shares can be transferred, making exit or succession easier.
• Improved Governance: Structured decision-making via the Board of Directors.

Requirements for Conversion

Here are the key requirements to convert a proprietorship into a private limited company:

• Legal Agreement: A takeover agreement must be executed to transfer the business.
• Memorandum of Association (MoA): Must include a clause to take over the existing business.
• Minimum Capital: While there is no fixed capital requirement, at least ₹1 lakh is commonly shown.
• Shareholding: The proprietor should hold at least 50% shares and voting rights post-conversion.
• Minimum Directors: At least 2 directors (including the proprietor).
• Asset Transfer: All tangible and intangible business assets must be transferred.

‍

Related Read: Difference between MOA and AOA

Prerequisites for Forming a Private Limited Company

Before converting, the following conditions must be fulfilled to form a Private Limited Company:

• Minimum 2 Directors: At least one must be a resident of India.
• Minimum 2 Shareholders: Can be the same as directors.
• DIN (Director Identification Number) for all directors.
• DSC (Digital Signature Certificate) for signing incorporation documents.
• Unique Name Approval through MCA's RUN or SPICe+ process.
• Registered Office Address: Proof of ownership or rent agreement with utility bill.

Conditions for Converting to a Sole Proprietorship

To legally convert a sole proprietorship into a private limited company, the following conditions must be satisfied:

1. Asset Transfer: All business assets must be transferred to the company without any monetary consideration except shares.
2. Shareholding Requirement: The Proprietor must own ≥50% of the total share capital.
3. No Other Benefits: No additional consideration, like cash or debt relief, is allowed.
4. Continuity of Business: The business must continue post-conversion for at least 5 years.
5. Valuation of Assets: Must be done by a Chartered Accountant to determine fair value.
6. Documentation: Legal agreement (slump sale or asset transfer) must be executed.

‍

Related Read: Difference Between Sole Proprietorship and One Person Company

‍

Documents Required for Conversion to Private Limited Company

Here’s a checklist of documents you’ll need:

For Proprietor (Now Director/Shareholder):

• PAN Card
• Aadhaar or Passport/Driver’s License
• Passport-sized photo
• Email and phone number
• Digital Signature (DSC)

For Business:

• Ownership/Rental proof of business premises
• Utility bill (not older than 2 months)
• NOC from the landlord if rented
• Statement of assets and liabilities (certified by a CA)

Procedure for Conversion of Proprietorship to Company

Follow these steps to convert your sole proprietorship into a private limited company:

Step 1: Name Reservation

Apply for the company name through RUN or SPICe+ Part A on the MCA portal.

Step 2: Get DSC

Obtain a Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) for all proposed directors.

Step 3: Draft MOA & AOA

• Include a clause in the Memorandum of Association (MoA) to take over the existing business.
• Prepare Articles of Association (AOA) for internal governance.

Step 4: File Incorporation via SPICe+

Submit SPICe+ forms (Part A and B) along with:

• PAN & TAN application
• MOA, AOA, declarations, affidavits, and other attachments.

Step 5: Execute Takeover Agreement

After the company's incorporation, a business takeover agreement must be signed between the proprietor and the company.

Step 6: Asset Transfer

Transfer all business assets and liabilities to the newly formed company.

Step 7: Post-Incorporation Tasks

• Open a company bank account
• Apply for GST, Shops & Establishment licenses (if required)
• File commencement of business (INC-20A) within 180 days

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

‍

What is an LC (Letter of Credit)?

A Letter of Credit (LC) is a document issued by a bank that guarantees payment to a seller on behalf of a buyer, provided that certain conditions are met. This financial instrument ensures payment security and mitigates risks associated with cross-border transactions. The issuance of an LC involves specific conditions, like the submission of required documents, which the bank reviews before releasing funds. It provides bank guarantees and incurs fees that are essential for its operation.

Examples of Letters of Credit

International Trade Example: A U.S. company wants to buy machinery from an Indian exporter. The U.S. company requests its bank to issue an LC to the Indian exporter. Once the exporter ships the machinery and presents the required documents to their bank, they receive payment from the issuing bank, ensuring trust and mitigating payment risk.

Domestic Transaction Example: A large retail chain uses an LC to purchase inventory from a local supplier. The LC guarantees that the supplier will receive payment as soon as they fulfill the delivery conditions outlined in the agreement.

Basics of a Letter of Credit Transaction

Applicant

The buyer who requests the LC from their bank. They initiate the process by applying for the LC and specifying the terms and conditions of the trade.

Beneficiary

The seller who receives payment through the LC. They must present all required documents correctly to receive payment.

Issuing Bank

The bank that issues the LC on behalf of the applicant. They verify the buyer's creditworthiness and commit to making the payment when conditions are met.

Negotiating Bank

The negotiating bank in LC that examines documents presented by the beneficiary and facilitates payment. They ensure all paperwork matches LC requirements perfectly.

The process begins when the applicant approaches their issuing bank for an LC. The issuing bank then coordinates with the negotiating bank to establish terms and verify documents before releasing any funds.

Importance of Letters of Credit

Secure Payments

They ensure that sellers receive payments without requiring advance payments, reducing risk for both parties involved in the letter of credit.

Facilitate Cross-Border Transactions

LCs simplify complex international transactions by providing a standardised payment mechanism across different countries.

Secure Business Funding

They provide businesses with necessary funding while verifying creditworthiness, helping companies maintain healthy cash flow.

Financial Assurance

LCs offer security when buyers cannot pay, acting as a guarantee backed by reliable banking institutions.

Advantages of Letters of Credit

Ease International Trade: Simplifies complex transactions across borders by providing a structured framework for payment and documentation.

Foster Global Business Connections: Builds trust between trading partners by removing payment uncertainty and providing bank-backed guarantees.

Provide Flexibility: Customisable terms to suit various transaction needs, including payment timing, shipping requirements, and document presentation.

Parties to Documentary Credit

Commercial/Trade Parties: The buyer and seller form the core of the transaction, initiating and completing the trade deal.

Banks: Issuing and advising banks serve as intermediaries ensuring secure payment and proper documentation.

Related Entities: Shipping lines and insurers support the transaction by handling logistics and risk management aspects.

Types of a Letter of Credit

Sight Credit

A Sight Credit allows instant payment upon presenting the correct documents, providing immediate access to funds for sellers. For example, if a businessman needs quick access to cash after shipping goods, they can use this type of credit.

Acceptance Credit/Time Credit

Acceptance or Time Credit involves bills that are accepted upon presentation and paid on specified due dates. This type allows sellers to receive payments after a set period.

Revocable Letter of Credit

A Revocable Letter of Credit can be canceled or modified by the issuing bank without beneficiary consent, which limits its reliability in ensuring secure transactions.

Irrevocable Letter of Credit

An Irrevocable Letter of Credit guarantees payment once certified by the exporter’s bank. This type provides security for international transactions and is often preferred by exporters due to its reliability.

Confirmed Letter of Credit

A Confirmed Letter of Credit involves both issuing and confirming banks. The confirming bank guarantees payment to the beneficiary, holding equal liability as the issuing bank, ensuring that payments will be honored upon proper presentation.

Back-to-Back Letter of Credit

This type involves issuing a second LC based on the security provided by the first LC. It is commonly used to secure payments for suppliers in international trade transactions.

Transferable Letter of Credit

A Transferable Letter of Credit allows the primary beneficiary to transfer credit partially or fully to another beneficiary, typically a supplier. However, once transferred, the second beneficiary cannot transfer it further.

Restricted Letter of Credit

A Restricted Letter of Credit specifies a particular bank responsible for payment, limiting its scope compared to unrestricted LCs. This type is often used when specific banks are preferred due to their reliability.

Revolving Letter of Credit

A Revolving Letter of Credit allows reuse after payments or drawings are made. This flexibility is beneficial for businesses requiring multiple shipments or ongoing transactions under one credit arrangement.

Precautions to be Taken

Verify Bank Reliability: The issuing bank must be reliable and well-known to both parties of the letter of credit. This helps minimise risks and ensures the LC will be honored when presented.

Local Bank Verification: It's essential to advise through an Indian bank and confirm the authenticity of the LC. The local bank can verify the legitimacy of the foreign bank and ensure all documents meet local regulations.

Clarify Financial Terms: Make sure to clearly establish who covers all bank charges and confirm freight payment terms as specified in contract agreements. This prevents disputes and unexpected costs during the transaction process.

Import Export Code

The Import Export Code (IEC) is a mandatory document required for all businesses involved in international trade. This code streamlines customs clearance, enables duty benefits, and ensures regulatory compliance. Through platforms like Razorpay Rize, businesses can obtain their IEC within 6-7 days which makes the process efficient and straightforward.

Frequently Asked Questions