Characteristics of Private Limited Company

What is Secretarial Audit?

A Secretarial Audit is an independent verification of a company’s compliance with corporate laws, rules, and regulations.

It helps companies to:

• Detect instances of non-compliance early.
• Promote good governance and transparency.
• Ensure that legal and procedural requirements are consistently met.

The audit is conducted by an independent professional, usually a Company Secretary (CS) holding a valid Certificate of Practice issued by the Institute of Company Secretaries of India (ICSI).

Secretarial Audit Applicability

Under the Companies Act, 2013, certain classes of companies are required to undergo a Secretarial Audit.

It is mandatory for:

• All Listed Companies.
• All Public Companies with:
  
  • Paid-up Share Capital of ₹50 crore or more, or
  • Turnover of ₹250 crore or more.
• All types of companies (including Private Companies) having outstanding borrowings of ₹100 crore or more from banks or financial institutions.

Secretarial Audit Report

The Secretarial Audit Report is the formal output of the audit process. It:

• Certifies whether the company is in compliance with applicable laws.
• Identifies any governance risks or gaps.
• Highlights areas of non-compliance and recommends corrective actions.

The report is prepared in Form MR-3, submitted to the Board of Directors, and included in the company’s Annual Report. As per Section 204 of the Companies Act, 2013, the audit can only be conducted and the report issued by a:

• Practising Company Secretary (PCS).
• Holding a valid Certificate of Practice from ICSI.

Scope of Secretarial Audit

The scope of a Secretarial Audit is broad and spans multiple laws, including but not limited to:

• Companies Act, 2013
• Securities Laws, including:
  
  • SEBI (LODR) Regulations
  • SEBI Takeover Code
  • SEBI Insider Trading Regulations
  • SEBI Listing Agreement
• Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA)
• Labour Laws
• Environmental Laws
• Industry-specific Regulations
• Secretarial Standards issued by ICSI

Additionally, the Secretarial Auditor also:

• Reviews the company’s systems and processes for compliance.
• Examines the Board structure and its functioning.
• May rely on reports from other professionals (auditors, legal counsel) for certain compliance areas.
  
  

{{comapany-reg-cta}}

Eligibility Criteria for the Appointment of a Secretarial Auditor

To be appointed as a Secretarial Auditor, the individual must:

• Be a qualified Company Secretary (CS) and a member of ICSI.
• Hold a valid Certificate of Practice (CoP) issued by ICSI.
• Have undergone relevant training in corporate governance and compliance.
• Maintain professional ethics and conduct in line with ICSI guidelines.

Only a Practising Company Secretary (PCS) is authorised to conduct and issue a Secretarial Audit Report.

Process of Secretarial Audit

The typical step-by-step process for conducting a Secretarial Audit is:

1. Preparation of a Compliance Checklist:
   Based on applicable laws and regulatory frameworks.
   
   
2. Compliance Verification:
   The auditor examines the company’s records, registers, filings, and processes.
   
   
3. Management Interaction:
   Discusses preliminary findings and areas of concern with management.
   
   
4. Recommendations and Corrective Actions:
   Advises management on how to address any gaps or non-compliance issues.
   
   
5. Preparation of the Final Report (MR-3):
   The auditor formally documents observations and recommendations.
   
   
6. Filing and Disclosure:
   The report is submitted to the Board and included in the Annual Report as required.

Features of Company Secretarial Audit

A Secretarial Audit is distinguished by several key features:

• Independent Audit:
  Conducted by an external Practising Company Secretary.
  
  
• Comprehensive Scope:
  Covers company law, securities law, tax law, labour law, environmental law, and other applicable legal frameworks.
  
  
• Systematic & Evidence-Based:
  Based on a thorough review of records and procedures.
  
  
• Board-Level Reporting:
  Findings and recommendations are directly reported to the Board of Directors.
  
  
• Governance-Focused:
  Designed to strengthen the company’s corporate governance practices.

Punishment for Default Secretarial Audit

Non-compliance with Secretarial Audit provisions carries penalties under:

Section 204(4) of the Companies Act, 2013:

The company, every officer in default, and the PCS (if found guilty) are liable to a fine of up to ₹5 lakh.

Section 448 (False Statements):

• Imprisonment up to 10 years, and/or
• Fine up to ₹10 lakh for making false statements in the audit report.

The Company Secretaries Act, 1980:

Disciplinary action against the Company Secretary may include:

• Suspension or cancellation of the Certificate of Practice.
• Monetary penalties.
• Professional misconduct proceedings.

Objectives of Secretarial Audit

The key objectives of Secretarial Audit are:

• Ensure the company complies with legal and regulatory frameworks.
• Identify non-compliance issues before they become liabilities.
• Promote good corporate governance.
• Protect the interests of stakeholders- investors, employees, customers, and regulators.
• Help management take corrective actions proactively.
• Prevent penalties and legal actions for non-compliance.

Benefits of Secretarial Audit

Conducting a Secretarial Audit offers many advantages:

• Enhances the company’s compliance culture.
• Reduces legal risks and the likelihood of penalties.
• Supports better corporate governance and transparency.
• Increases stakeholder confidence- important for investors and regulators.
• Helps Directors and Management make more informed decisions.
• Facilitates continuous improvement in internal processes and systems.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a Section 8 Company?

A Section 8 Company is a special category of non-profit organisation registered under Section 8 of the Companies Act, 2013. These companies are formed for charitable or social purposes such as:

• Education
• Promotion of arts and culture
• Social welfare
• Research
• Environmental protection
• Sports development

Key Characteristics:

• No profit distribution: Profits, if any, are reinvested in promoting the organisation's objectives.
• Name exemption: They do not use “Limited” or “Private Limited” in their names.
• Regulatory advantages: Enjoy exemptions on stamp duty, income tax (if 12A/80G registered), and some ROC compliances.

Related Read: What is ROC Filing & Why It's Necessary?

Section 8 Companies differ from regular for-profit businesses in that their core purpose is impact, not income, which doesn’t make compliance any less important.

Section 8 Company Compliance

Maintaining compliance is not just about ticking legal boxes—it’s essential to retain the company’s non-profit status, ensure transparency, and stay eligible for grants, tax benefits, and government support.

Types of Compliance:

1. Time-Based Compliance
   Based on fixed deadlines (e.g., annual returns, AGMs)
   
   
2. Event-Based Compliance
   Triggered by corporate actions (e.g., change of directors, share allotment)
   
   
3. Criteria-Based Compliance
   Based on financial thresholds or specific business conditions (e.g., GST annual returns if turnover exceeds ₹2 crore)

A. Compliance Requirements Under the Companies Act, 2013 (and Related Rules)

Here's a breakdown of key compliances that every Section 8 Company must fulfil:

Planning to start a non-profit? Begin your Section 8 Company registration with expert assistance today.

B. Compliance Obligations Under FEMA Regulations

If your Section 8 Company receives foreign investments or donations, FEMA compliance becomes mandatory.

C. GST Compliance as per the Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017

Section 8 Companies may need GST registration if their annual turnover exceeds the prescribed limits or if they engage in taxable activities.

Thresholds:

₹20 lakh (services) or ₹40 lakh (goods) for most states

Monthly/Quarterly Returns:

Annual Returns (If applicable based on turnover):

D. Income Tax Compliance Under the Income Tax Act, 1961

While many Section 8 companies register under 12A and 80G to claim income tax exemptions, they must still follow standard tax compliances.

E. Statutory Compliance Under Applicable Labour Laws

Section 8 Companies employing staff are also required to comply with applicable labour laws, such as EPF, ESI, and state-specific welfare fund contributions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Difference Between Company and Partnership Firm

A company and partnership difference is rooted in their legal definitions and formation processes. A company is an incorporated entity under the Companies Act, 2013, with shareholders owning the business. Conversely, a partnership firm is an unincorporated association of individuals governed by the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, where partners collectively own and manage the business.

Here's a table highlighting the main differences:

Looking to register your Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) effortlessly? Get started with Razorpay Rize today and streamline your business registration process!

Understanding a Company

Definition of Company

A company is a distinct legal entity formed by an association of people to carry on a business. The Indian Companies Act of 2013, Section 2(20), defines "company" as "a company incorporated under the Companies Act 2013 or any previous company law." Companies can be public or private, with private limited companies having 2-200 members and public companies having at least 7 members with no upper limit.

Types of Company

Here are the types of companies:

1. Private limited company: A privately held company with 2-200 members, where the transfer of shares is restricted.
2. Public limited company: A company that can invite the public to subscribe to its shares, with a minimum of 7 members and no upper limit.
3. One Person Company: A company with only one member.

Characteristics of a Company

• Separate legal entity
• Limited liability for members
• Perpetual succession
• Transferable shares
• Managed by Board of Directors
• Stringent compliance requirements

Company registration involves a formal process, including filing Memorandum and Articles of Association, obtaining DIN for directors, and submitting requisite documents to the Registrar of Companies.

Understanding a Partnership Firm

A partnership firm is a business structure where two or more partners come together to run a business collectively. The partners share the profits and bear the losses of the business in the agreed proportion.

Definition of Partnership Firm

A partnership firm is a business structure formed by an association of two or more people who agree to share business profits. The Indian Partnership Act of 1932, Section 4, defines Partnership as "The relation between persons who have agreed to share profits of business carried on by all or any of them acting for all."

Partnerships can be general partnerships where all partners have unlimited liability, or limited liability partnerships (LLPs) with both general and limited partners. The key differences between a company and partnership relate to legal structure, liability, management, ownership transfer, regulatory compliance, and taxation.

Characteristics of a Partnership Firm

• Formed by an agreement between partners
• No separate legal entity from partners
• Unlimited liability for partners
• Profit sharing as per partnership deed
• Jointly managed by partners
• Fewer compliance requirements compared to companies
• Ideal for small and medium-sized businesses

Similarities Between Company and Partnership Firm

Despite their difference between company and partnership firm, they share some common characteristics:

• Formed for carrying on a business
• Require registration with relevant authorities
• Aim to earn profits
• Governed by specific laws and regulations
• Require maintenance of books of accounts
• Can sue and be sued in their own name

Which One Should You Choose?

Choosing between a company and a partnership depends on business goals, liability, taxation, and compliance requirements. Below are hypothetical examples to help you decide.

1. Business Size & Growth Potential

• Choose a Company: If you plan to scale your business, attract investors, or raise capital, a company structure is ideal.
  
  • Example: Raj and Meera start an AI-based edtech startup. They plan to raise funds from investors and expand globally. To do this, they register as a private limited company and issue shares to investors.
• Choose a Partnership: If you prefer a small-scale business with direct decision-making, a partnership is a better choice.
  
  • Example: Aarav and Kunal start a custom furniture workshop in their city. Since they don’t need external funding and want to split profits equally, they form a partnership firm.

2. Liability Protection

• Company: Offers limited liability, meaning the owners’ personal assets are protected in case of losses.
  
  • Example: Neha runs an organic skincare brand. A customer files a lawsuit over an allergic reaction. Since Neha's business is a registered company, her personal assets remain safe, and only the company’s assets are at risk.
• Partnership: In a general partnership, partners have unlimited liability, meaning personal assets can be used to settle business debts.
  
  • Example: Vikram and Ramesh own a small event management business. They take a loan for an event but incur heavy losses. As a partnership, both partners are personally responsible for repaying the loan, even if it means selling personal assets.

Note: In a Limited Liability Partnership (LLP), personal liability is restricted.

3. Taxation Structure

• Company: Pays corporate tax, and profits distributed as dividends may be taxed separately.
  
  • Example: An IT consulting firm is structured as a private limited company. While it pays corporate tax, its owners benefit from lower tax rates on dividends compared to individual income tax.
• Partnership: Profits are taxed at the individual level, often leading to lower overall tax liability.
  
  • Example: A local bakery run by two partners is taxed based on individual earnings, avoiding corporate tax obligations and reducing overall tax liability.

4. Compliance & Legal Requirements

• Company: Requires mandatory registration, regular filings, audits, and compliance with corporate laws.
  
  • Example: A group of engineers launches a renewable energy startup. Since they have multiple stakeholders and need regulatory approvals, they register as a company, ensuring compliance with industry standards.
• Partnership: Has minimal legal requirements, making it easier and cost-effective to manage.
  
  • Example: A duo running a content writing agency operates as a partnership to avoid the hassle of extensive compliance, annual filings, and statutory audits.

5. Business Continuity & Stability

• Company: Has a separate legal identity, meaning the business continues even if owners change.
  
  • Example: A software firm registered as a company continues operations after one founder exits by transferring shares to a new investor.
• Partnership: Typically dissolves if a partner exits unless an agreement states otherwise.
  
  • Example: A law firm operating as a partnership dissolves after one partner retires, requiring a new agreement to continue operations.

In conclusion, understanding the difference between partnership and company is crucial for entrepreneurs when deciding on the most suitable business structure. While a Sole Proprietorship offers simplicity and control, a partnership firm enables collaboration and shared responsibility. On the other hand, a company, particularly a private limited company, provides limited liability and greater scalability. Consider factors such as liability, management, compliance, and growth prospects when choosing between a partnership vs company. Seek professional advice to make an informed decision aligned with your business objectives and risk appetite.

Frequently Asked Questions: