Defunct Company: Definition, Causes, and Example

What is Equity Dilution?

Equity dilution refers to the reduction in existing shareholders’ ownership percentage due to the issuance of new shares. Although it doesn't necessarily mean a loss in actual monetary value, it does mean reduced voting power, ownership stake, and potential control over the company.

For example, if a founder owns 50% of a company before a funding round and 40% after new shares are issued to investors, the 10% drop is equity dilution.

Causes of Equity Dilution in India

Several scenarios in India lead to equity dilution:

• Fundraising through equity: When a company raises capital by issuing new shares to investors (angel, VC, PE).
• ESOPs (Employee Stock Option Plans): Issuing shares to employees for retention and motivation.
• Convertible instruments: When convertible debentures or notes convert to equity.
• Mergers and acquisitions: New shares issued as part of a transaction.
• Bonus or rights issues: Depending on the structure, these can also dilute holdings if not proportionally subscribed.

Impact of Equity Dilution

Dilution can affect stakeholders in various ways:

• Founders: Loss of control or voting power if too much equity is given away early.
• Investors: Reduced ownership percentages, which may affect decision-making influence.
• Employees: If ESOPs are diluted too often, their potential upside gets reduced.
• Company valuation: Though dilution reduces percentage ownership, it can lead to growth and higher valuations, offsetting the effect in monetary terms.

How Does Share Dilution Happen?

Share dilution occurs when a company issues additional shares, reducing the ownership percentage of existing shareholders. While the total number of shares increases, each existing shareholder’s slice of the pie becomes smaller — unless they participate in the new issue.

Here are the most common ways share dilution happens in India:

1. Fundraising (Equity Rounds)

During seed, Series A, or later funding rounds, new investors are issued fresh equity. To accommodate them, the company increases its authorised and paid-up share capital, diluting the percentage held by existing shareholders.

Example:
A founder owns 100% of a startup with 1,00,000 shares. After raising funds from investors who are issuing 50,000 new shares, the founder’s ownership drops to 66.67%.

2. Issuing ESOPs (Employee Stock Option Plans)

Startups often set aside 5–15% of their cap table for ESOPs to attract and retain top talent. These options, once vested and exercised, convert into shares — reducing the percentage stake of other shareholders.

3. Conversion of Convertible Instruments

Instruments like convertible notes, SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity), or CCDs (Compulsorily Convertible Debentures) convert into equity at a future date. When they convert, new shares are issued, which dilute existing ownership.

4. Mergers or Acquisitions

In some mergers or acquisitions, equity may be offered as part of the consideration to the merging entity or its shareholders. This leads to the issuance of new shares and causes dilution.

5. Bonus Shares to Select Stakeholders

Occasionally, a company might issue bonus shares to certain shareholders or employees as incentives, which can result in uneven dilution.

Reasons for Equity Dilution

• Capital infusion: To fund growth, R&D, hiring, marketing, etc.
• Strategic partnerships: Issuing equity to partners or advisors.
• Debt conversion: Debt turning into equity through convertible notes.
• Regulatory compliance: SEBI regulations may require public companies to maintain a certain free float, triggering new issuance.

Managing Equity Dilution in India

Equity dilution is inevitable as your startup grows — but managing it smartly can protect both your control and long-term value. Indian founders must understand the tools, strategies, and legal frameworks available to reduce unnecessary dilution and align all stakeholders.

1. Plan Your Cap Table Early

Create a 5–7 year cap table projection. Visualise future funding rounds, ESOP pools, convertible instruments, and expected dilution at each stage.

2. Raise What You Need, Not What You Can

Avoid over-raising in early rounds. Each round of funding comes at the cost of equity. Only raise what’s required to hit the next set of milestones.

3. Negotiate Better Valuations

Valuation is key to how much equity you give up. Strengthen your fundamentals, traction, and pitch to negotiate higher valuations, thus minimising dilution per rupee raised.

4. Use Convertible Instruments Strategically

Instruments like SAFE notes or CCDs can delay dilution until a priced round. Use them in early or bridge rounds to preserve equity while bringing in capital.

5. Be Thoughtful with ESOP Allocation

ESOPs are critical to building a strong team, but don’t over-allocate too early. Start with a lean pool (5–10%) and expand as your team grows and funding allows.

6. Include Anti-Dilution Provisions (If You're an Investor or Co-Founder)

While often investor-friendly, certain anti-dilution clauses can protect your equity in down rounds. Founders should understand these clauses and negotiate fair terms.

7. Consider Non-Dilutive Capital

Explore grants, government schemes (like Startup India Seed Fund, MeitY TIDE, or NIDHI), or revenue-based financing. These options offer capital with no equity dilution.

8. Maintain Founder Alignment

If co-founders have significantly unequal stakes, align expectations early. Future dilution can compound tensions if not addressed at the start.

How Shareholders Can Handle Equity Dilution?

• Pre-emptive rights: Ensure agreements include rights to participate in future rounds to maintain shareholding.
• Anti-dilution clauses: Particularly for investors, these can protect them from value dilution in down rounds.
• Monitor ESOP pools: Oversized ESOP pools dilute all shareholders.
• Regular cap table reviews: Stay updated to avoid surprises in ownership shifts.

Conclusion

Equity dilution is a natural part of a growing business, especially in India's thriving startup and investment landscape. While it may seem negative on the surface, it often enables access to capital, talent, and partnerships that fuel long-term value creation. 

The key lies in understanding, planning, and strategically managing dilution to protect stakeholder interests while supporting the company’s growth.

‍

Eligibility

• Should be recognised by DPIIT.
• Startups should not have received more than Rs 10 lakh of monetary support under other significant government schemes.
• The Startup shall have been in existence for no more than two years at the time of application.
• Should be using technology as its core product or service to create innovative solutions in different sectors.
• Must have a business idea to develop the product with a scope of scaling
• According to the Companies Act of 2013 and the SEBI (ICDR) Regulations of 2018, Indian promoters must own at least 51 percent of the company at the time of application to the incubator.
• The seed support is generally available in grants and debt/convertible debentures.

Application procedure for Startups

The application procedure for availing the seed fund from the incubators by the startups under the StartUp India Seed Fund Scheme is as follows:

Startup India Registration

• Go to https://seedfund.startupindia.gov.in/.
• On the top right side of the homepage, click the 'Login' button, then the 'Create an Account' option at the bottom of the "Login" tab.
• The ‘Startup India’ registration page will open.
• After filling out the form, click the 'Register' button.
• An OTP will be sent. Enter the OTP and click the ‘Submit’ button.

Startup India Seed Fund Application

• Go to the website again and click on the ‘Apply Now’ button on the right-hand side of the homepage.
• Click on the ‘Apply Now’ button under the ‘For Startups’ option and log in using the username and password registered.
• The application form will open. Put in all the details, upload the documents, and click on the ‘Submit’ button.
• The application will be submitted for the selection of the startup.

Selection of Startups for the Scheme

The Eligible Incubator will select startups for this scheme based on the following criteria:

• Idea
• Feasibility
• Novelty
• Fund Utilization Plan
• Business Plan
• Presentation
• Potential Impact

Benefits

To register a company in the U.S., several essential criteria must be met.

• Under this scheme, up to Rs 50 lakh in financial assistance will be provided to startups at an early stage through incubators.
• The incubator will disburse the seed fund to an eligible startup:
  - As a grant for validation of “prototype development, proof of concept or product trials”-  Up to Rs. 20 Lakh        
  - Investment for commercialization, market-entry, or scaling up through debt-linked instruments - Up to Rs. 50 Lakh
• Once incubated, physical infrastructure, testing support, mentoring for prototype or commercialization, human resources, and legal compliances are provided to the startups, all by the incubators.
• For eligible startups, income tax and capital gains tax exemptions are available.

Post funding process

Each incubator must track specific criteria for each beneficiary startup. Every beneficiary startup must present the reports to its incubators periodically. The data is submitted to Startup India in real-time via their web dashboards and further to the EAC quarterly. Each Startup’s return on investment is also reported by the designated incubator.

• Proof of concept
• Prototype development
• Progress of product development & field trials
• Turnover of startup
• Progress of market launch
• Quantum of loan, angel, or VC funding raised
• Jobs created by startup

Frequently Asked Questions

Income Tax Return

An Income Tax Return is a document submitted to the Income Tax Department to report your income, deductions, and tax payments for a financial year. There are seven types of ITR forms, including ITR-1, ITR-2, ITR-3, ITR-4, ITR-5, and ITR-6, each applicable to different taxpayers. Filing ITR before the due date is essential to avoid penalties and legal issues.

Applicable ITR Forms for Companies

The type of ITR for a company depends on its structure and income classification. Different business entities must file specific ITR forms to comply with tax regulations:

• ITR-4: Suitable for firms (excluding LLPs) with income up to ₹50 lakhs under Sections 44AD, 44ADA, and 44AE.
  
• ITR-5: Applicable for LLPs and partnership firms, except those required to file ITR-7.
  
• ITR-6: Used by companies that do not claim tax exemptions under Section 11 (income from property used for charitable or religious purposes).
  
• ITR-7: Mandatory for entities filing under Sections 139(4A), 139(4B), 139(4C), and 139(4D), such as trusts and political parties.
  

ITR-4 Form (Sugam) – For Firms Other Than LLPs

ITR-4 is designed for individuals, Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs), and partnership firms (excluding Limited Liability Partnerships) that opt for the presumptive taxation scheme under Sections 44AD, 44ADA, and 44AE. This scheme simplifies tax calculations for small businesses and professionals.

Applicability Criteria:

• Eligible Taxpayers: Individuals, HUFs, and firms (excluding  Limited Liability Partnership) with business or professional income.
  
• Residency Requirement: Only applicable to a resident other than not ordinarily resident.
  
• Income Sources:
  
  • Business income under Section 44AD (small businesses).
    
  • Professional income under Section 44ADA (specified professions).
    
  • Income from goods transportation under Section 44AE.
    

In certain cases, if your business meets specific conditions, you may also need to submit Form 3CA/3CB and Form 3CD for a tax audit.

ITR-5 – For LLPs and Partnerships

ITR-5 is an income tax return form applicable to Limited Liability Partnerships, partnership firms, and other non-individual entities such as Associations of Persons (AOPs), Bodies of Individuals (BOIs), artificial juridical persons, and investment funds.

These entities must file ITR-5 to report their income, deductions, and tax liabilities to the Income Tax Department. Filing this form ensures compliance with tax laws and helps avoid penalties. However, companies required to file ITR-7 cannot use ITR-5 for tax filing.

ITR-6 – For Companies That Are Not Claiming Exemption Under Section 11

ITR-6 is an income tax return form for companies that are not claiming exemptions under Section 11, which applies to income from property held for charitable or religious purposes.

• It is mandatory for private limited companies, public limited companies, and One Person Companies (OPCs).
  
• Not applicable to Limited Liability Partnerships, as they must file ITR-5.
  

Filing ITR-6 accurately is compulsory for all companies that do not qualify for exemptions under Section 11. Timely filing is essential to avoid penalties and ensure compliance.

ITR-7 – For Companies

ITR-7 is an income tax return form for companies, firms, trusts, and other entities required to file returns under Sections 139(4A), 139(4B), 139(4C), and 139(4D) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. It applies to organisations that do not qualify for other ITR categories but must still comply with tax regulations.

Entities Required to File ITR-7:

• Registered charitable or religious trusts
  
• Societies and other institutions for charitable purposes
  
• Educational institutions and universities
  
• Scientific research associations
  
• News agencies
  
• Political parties registered under Section 29A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951
  
• Bodies set up for religious or charitable purposes
  

Filing ITR-7 is essential for these entities to comply with tax laws, report income, and claim applicable exemptions.

Details Required in an ITR Form

The information required in an Income Tax Return form depends on the type of taxpayer and income sources. However, certain key details must be included in all ITR filings.

• Personal Information: Name, PAN, date of birth, contact details, and residential address and other personal details.
  
• Income Sources: Details of salary, business or profession, capital gains, rental income, interest, and other earnings.
  
• Deductions & Exemptions: Deductions and exemptions include the tax benefits you claim under different sections of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
  
• Tax Payments: Information on the taxes you have already paid, such as advance tax, self-assessment tax, and Tax Deducted at Source (TDS).
  
• Foreign Assets & Income: If applicable, disclosure of overseas bank accounts, investments, and earnings.
  

Filing an ITR with correct details ensures timely processing and avoids unnecessary scrutiny from tax authorities.

Important Deadlines for Filing Company ITR

Due Dates for Filing ITR-6

• If audit is required under the Income Tax Act – 31st October of the assessment year.
  
• If a report in Form No. 3CEB (for international transactions) is required – 30th November of the assessment year.
  
• If audit is not required – 31st July of the assessment year.

Due Dates for Filing ITR-7

• For entities not requiring an audit – 31st July of the assessment year.
  
• For entities requiring an audit – 30th September of the assessment year.
  

It is important to note that ITR filing deadlines may change based on updates or extensions announced by the Income Tax Department. You should stay informed about official notifications to avoid missing any revised due dates.

As per Section 234F, a late filing fee of ₹5,000 is applicable if the return is filed after the due date under Section 139(1). However, if the total income is ₹5 lakh or less, the penalty is reduced to ₹1,000.

Common Mistakes to Avoid While Filing Company ITR

Incorrect Form Selection

Selecting the wrong ITR form is one of the most frequent mistakes companies make. The type of ITR form a company must file depends on its structure and nature of operations. ITR-5 is applicable for LLP and partnership firms, whereas ITR-6 is meant for most companies except those claiming exemptions under Section 11. ITR-7 is required for entities like trusts and NGOs. Filing the incorrect form can lead to rejection or discrepancies in tax assessment.

Incomplete Financial Disclosures

A company is required to disclose all sources of income, deductions, and financial transactions in its ITR. Failing to provide complete details of revenue, expenses, capital gains, investments, liabilities, and foreign assets can result in tax penalties or audits. Accurate disclosure ensures that tax authorities have a clear understanding of the company’s financial position.

Missing Audit Report Submission

Companies that meet specific turnover or income thresholds are required to undergo a tax audit as per the Income Tax Act. If a tax audit is applicable, the company must submit the audit report before filing the ITR. Missing this step can lead to legal consequences, penalties, or delays in return processing. It is important to verify whether the company falls under the audit requirement and ensure timely submission of audit reports.

Frequently Asked Questions