Capital Redemption Reserve: Definition, Uses, Tax Benefits & More

Difference Between Company and Partnership Firm

A company and partnership difference is rooted in their legal definitions and formation processes. A company is an incorporated entity under the Companies Act, 2013, with shareholders owning the business. Conversely, a partnership firm is an unincorporated association of individuals governed by the Indian Partnership Act, 1932, where partners collectively own and manage the business.

Here's a table highlighting the main differences:

Looking to register your Limited Liability Partnership (LLP) effortlessly? Get started with Razorpay Rize today and streamline your business registration process!

Understanding a Company

Definition of Company

A company is a distinct legal entity formed by an association of people to carry on a business. The Indian Companies Act of 2013, Section 2(20), defines "company" as "a company incorporated under the Companies Act 2013 or any previous company law." Companies can be public or private, with private limited companies having 2-200 members and public companies having at least 7 members with no upper limit.

Types of Company

Here are the types of companies:

1. Private limited company: A privately held company with 2-200 members, where the transfer of shares is restricted.
2. Public limited company: A company that can invite the public to subscribe to its shares, with a minimum of 7 members and no upper limit.
3. One Person Company: A company with only one member.

Characteristics of a Company

• Separate legal entity
• Limited liability for members
• Perpetual succession
• Transferable shares
• Managed by Board of Directors
• Stringent compliance requirements

Company registration involves a formal process, including filing Memorandum and Articles of Association, obtaining DIN for directors, and submitting requisite documents to the Registrar of Companies.

Understanding a Partnership Firm

A partnership firm is a business structure where two or more partners come together to run a business collectively. The partners share the profits and bear the losses of the business in the agreed proportion.

Definition of Partnership Firm

A partnership firm is a business structure formed by an association of two or more people who agree to share business profits. The Indian Partnership Act of 1932, Section 4, defines Partnership as "The relation between persons who have agreed to share profits of business carried on by all or any of them acting for all."

Partnerships can be general partnerships where all partners have unlimited liability, or limited liability partnerships (LLPs) with both general and limited partners. The key differences between a company and partnership relate to legal structure, liability, management, ownership transfer, regulatory compliance, and taxation.

Characteristics of a Partnership Firm

• Formed by an agreement between partners
• No separate legal entity from partners
• Unlimited liability for partners
• Profit sharing as per partnership deed
• Jointly managed by partners
• Fewer compliance requirements compared to companies
• Ideal for small and medium-sized businesses

Similarities Between Company and Partnership Firm

Despite their difference between company and partnership firm, they share some common characteristics:

• Formed for carrying on a business
• Require registration with relevant authorities
• Aim to earn profits
• Governed by specific laws and regulations
• Require maintenance of books of accounts
• Can sue and be sued in their own name

Which One Should You Choose?

Choosing between a company and a partnership depends on business goals, liability, taxation, and compliance requirements. Below are hypothetical examples to help you decide.

1. Business Size & Growth Potential

• Choose a Company: If you plan to scale your business, attract investors, or raise capital, a company structure is ideal.
  
  • Example: Raj and Meera start an AI-based edtech startup. They plan to raise funds from investors and expand globally. To do this, they register as a private limited company and issue shares to investors.
• Choose a Partnership: If you prefer a small-scale business with direct decision-making, a partnership is a better choice.
  
  • Example: Aarav and Kunal start a custom furniture workshop in their city. Since they don’t need external funding and want to split profits equally, they form a partnership firm.

2. Liability Protection

• Company: Offers limited liability, meaning the owners’ personal assets are protected in case of losses.
  
  • Example: Neha runs an organic skincare brand. A customer files a lawsuit over an allergic reaction. Since Neha's business is a registered company, her personal assets remain safe, and only the company’s assets are at risk.
• Partnership: In a general partnership, partners have unlimited liability, meaning personal assets can be used to settle business debts.
  
  • Example: Vikram and Ramesh own a small event management business. They take a loan for an event but incur heavy losses. As a partnership, both partners are personally responsible for repaying the loan, even if it means selling personal assets.

Note: In a Limited Liability Partnership (LLP), personal liability is restricted.

3. Taxation Structure

• Company: Pays corporate tax, and profits distributed as dividends may be taxed separately.
  
  • Example: An IT consulting firm is structured as a private limited company. While it pays corporate tax, its owners benefit from lower tax rates on dividends compared to individual income tax.
• Partnership: Profits are taxed at the individual level, often leading to lower overall tax liability.
  
  • Example: A local bakery run by two partners is taxed based on individual earnings, avoiding corporate tax obligations and reducing overall tax liability.

4. Compliance & Legal Requirements

• Company: Requires mandatory registration, regular filings, audits, and compliance with corporate laws.
  
  • Example: A group of engineers launches a renewable energy startup. Since they have multiple stakeholders and need regulatory approvals, they register as a company, ensuring compliance with industry standards.
• Partnership: Has minimal legal requirements, making it easier and cost-effective to manage.
  
  • Example: A duo running a content writing agency operates as a partnership to avoid the hassle of extensive compliance, annual filings, and statutory audits.

5. Business Continuity & Stability

• Company: Has a separate legal identity, meaning the business continues even if owners change.
  
  • Example: A software firm registered as a company continues operations after one founder exits by transferring shares to a new investor.
• Partnership: Typically dissolves if a partner exits unless an agreement states otherwise.
  
  • Example: A law firm operating as a partnership dissolves after one partner retires, requiring a new agreement to continue operations.

In conclusion, understanding the difference between partnership and company is crucial for entrepreneurs when deciding on the most suitable business structure. While a Sole Proprietorship offers simplicity and control, a partnership firm enables collaboration and shared responsibility. On the other hand, a company, particularly a private limited company, provides limited liability and greater scalability. Consider factors such as liability, management, compliance, and growth prospects when choosing between a partnership vs company. Seek professional advice to make an informed decision aligned with your business objectives and risk appetite.

Frequently Asked Questions:

What is Form 11 and How to File It? 

Form 11 is an Annual Return of LLP. Every LLP in India must file with the Registrar of Companies (RoC) under the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008. It serves as a comprehensive summary of the LLP's management and structure for the financial year.

Here’s what Form 11 LLP typically includes:

1. General Information:
   
   • LLP Name.
   • LLP Identification Number (LLPIN).
   • Date of Incorporation.
2. Partner Information:
   
   • Names and details of designated and other partners.
   • Changes in partnership during the financial year, such as additions, resignations, or reassignments.
3. Contribution Details:
   
   • The total contribution received by the LLP from partners.
   • Contributions made by individual partners during the year.
4. Declaration of Compliance:
   
   • A confirmation that the LLP has met its statutory obligations during the year.

Steps to File Form 11

Filing Form 11 is a straightforward process. Follow these steps to ensure compliance:

1. Download Form 11:

Visit the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) portal and download the latest version of Form 11.

2. Fill in Basic Details: 

Provide the LLP’s basic details, including:

• LLPIN.
• Date of Incorporation.
• Business activities during the financial year.

3. Enter Partner Information:
   
   • List all designated and non-designated partners.
   • Include details of any changes in partnership, such as additions or removals.
4. Attach Supporting Documents:

Upload any supporting documentation, including agreements or resolutions, if applicable.

5. Certify the Form:

Ensure the form is digitally signed by one of the designated partners using a Digital Signature Certificate (DSC).

6. Submit on MCA Portal:

Upload the completed form and pay the prescribed filing fee. Fees depend on the LLP’s total contribution as per the LLP Agreement.

Due Date for Filing Annual Return (Form 11)

The due date for filing Form 11 is May 30 every year, covering the financial year ending on March 31.

Important Note:

• Filing Form 11 is mandatory regardless of whether the LLP has started its business. Even dormant LLPs are required to submit their annual return.

If you don’t file before Form 11 LLP’s due date, you can be penalised, so it's crucial to adhere to the timeline.

Additional Fee (Penalty) for Belated Filing of Annual Return (Form 11)

Failure to file Form 11 on or before May 30 can lead to significant financial penalties and legal complications. 

• A penalty of LLP form 11 late fee of ₹100 per day is imposed for each day the filing is delayed.
• The penalty has no upper limit, which means prolonged delays can result in substantial fines.

Continued non-compliance may lead to the LLP being marked as inactive by the RoC. While the designated partners may face disqualification from holding similar roles in other companies or LLPs.

What Are The Prerequisites?

Before filing, ensure that you’re fulfilling certain Form 11 LLp requirements:

1. The LLP is registered and has an active status on the MCA portal.
2. A valid DPIN of the Partner.
3. A Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) is available for at least one designated partner.
4. All pending compliance forms, such as Form 3 (LLP Agreement), have been filed.

What Are the Documents to be Submitted Along with Form 11?

Depending on the changes or updates during the year, the following documents are required for Form 11 LLP submission:

1. List of Partners:

A detailed list of designated and other partners, including their roles and contributions.

2. Contribution Proof:

Evidence of the capital contributed by each partner during the financial year.

3. Supporting Agreements:

Copies of resolutions or amendments to the LLP Agreement, if applicable.

4. Additional Documents:

Any other documents as required by the MCA portal based on the LLP’s activities.

{{llp-cta}}

Important Aspects to Note While Filing Annual Return for LLP

While LLP annual filling might seem straightforward, there are key details and considerations that can make a big difference. Overlooking these aspects could lead to errors, delays, or unnecessary penalties. To help you navigate this process smoothly, here are some important points to remember while filing your LLP’s annual return.

1. Accuracy of Partner Details:

Ensure the names, roles, and contributions of all partners are correctly listed, as discrepancies can lead to rejections or penalties.

2. Difference Between Forms:

Do not confuse Form 11 for LLP with Form 8, which deals with the financial health and solvency of the LLP. Both must be filed annually.

3. Digital Signature Validity:

Verify the validity of the Digital Signature Certificate (DSC) before submission to avoid technical issues.

Certification in Annual Return (Form 11)

Certification plays a crucial role in the filing of Form 11 (Annual Return) for an LLP. It ensures that the information provided is accurate and compliant with the statutory requirements. 

While the form can be filed by the designated partner(s), certain conditions require additional certification by a practising professional, such as a Company Secretary.

When is Certification Required?

For LLPs meeting certain financial thresholds, certification of Form 11 by a professional ( Company Secretary) is mandatory:

• If the LLP’s contribution exceeds ₹50 lakhs, or
• If its turnover exceeds ₹5 crores,

Frequently Asked Questions

DIR-3 KYC

Form DIR-3 KYC is an important annual compliance step that every person holding a Director Identification Number (DIN) must complete. Whether you're currently a director in a company or not, if you have a DIN, you must file this form each year.

The Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) mandates filing this form every year to ensure that directors’ records are current and accurate.

Failing to file this form within the deadline will lead to the DIN being marked as “Deactivated due to non-filing of DIR-3 KYC,” restricting a director from participating in company matters until compliance is restored.

Purpose of the Form DIR-3 KYC

The purpose of DIR-3 KYC is to keep director information in sync with official records and maintain a transparent and compliant corporate ecosystem. It ensures that directors update their information annually with the MCA.

Who Has to File e-Form DIR-3 KYC?

Every individual who holds a DIN, regardless of whether they are currently serving as a director, must file the e-Form DIR-3 KYC with the MCA each year. This includes:

• Directors of private and public companies
  
• Individuals whose DIN is active or approved but inactive
  

There are no exemptions, so it's essential to comply regardless of your status or position.

Applicable Fee For Form DIR-3 KYC

• Filing Fee: Free if filed on or before September 30
  
• Penalty: ₹5,000 if filed after the due date, and the DIN will be deactivated until payment is made
  

Due Date for Filing DIR 3 KYC Form

The KYC form must be submitted by September 30 every year. There are two formats:

• DIR-3 KYC: For first-time filers or those updating details
  
• DIR-3 KYC Web: For those who have filed previously and have no changes
  

Penalties for Late Filing of the Form DIR-3 KYC

Missing the September 30 deadline results in:

• DIN Deactivation
  
• A penalty of ₹5,000 to reactivate the DIN
  

Documents Required to File DIR-3 KYC Form

Directors need the following documents:

• Self-attested PAN card
  
• Self-attested Aadhaar card
  
• Passport (if available)
  
• Valid mobile number and email ID
  
• Digital Signature Certificate (DSC)
  

Key Verification Steps for Filing the Form DIR-3 KYC

Filing the DIR-3 KYC form may seem straightforward, but following the steps carefully is important to ensure successful submission and avoid any delays or penalties. Here's a detailed breakdown of the process:

Step 1: Collect Personal Documents

Before starting the filing process, gather all the required documents.

Step 2: Ensure Accuracy of Details

Ensure that all the information you enter in the form matches the details mentioned in your official documents (especially PAN and Aadhaar). Any mismatch can lead to rejection or delays in processing.

Step 3: Verify with OTP

Once you enter your email ID and mobile number, an OTP (One-Time Password) will be sent for verification. This is an essential part of the KYC process and ensures that your contact information is valid and belongs to you.

Step 4: Sign with a Digital Signature Certificate (DSC)

The DIR-3 KYC form must be digitally signed by the director using a valid DSC (Class 2 or Class 3). This step certifies the authenticity of the information being submitted.

Step 5: Get it attested by a Professional

After signing the form with your DSC, the form must be certified by a practising professional like a Chartered Accountant (CA) or a Company Secretary (CS). The professional must verify the form’s contents and affix their own digital signature. Their membership number, certificate of practice number, and contact details must also be provided.

Step 6: Upload the Form to the MCA Portal

Once the form is digitally signed and attested, upload it on the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA) portal.

Process After Submitting the DIR-3 KYC Form

Once the DIR-3 KYC form is successfully submitted on the MCA portal, the following steps take place:

• SRN Generation: An SRN (Service Request Number) is instantly generated upon submission. This SRN is important for tracking your application and for any future correspondence with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs (MCA).
  
• Email Acknowledgement: The director receives an acknowledgment email at their registered email address. This email confirms the receipt and approval of the DIR-3 KYC form and usually includes a receipt of the submission. It is advisable to save this receipt for your records.
  
• MCA Verification: The MCA system verifies the details provided in the form. If all information is correct, the status of the Director Identification Number (DIN) is updated to reflect successful KYC completion.
  
• Error Handling: If there are any errors or discrepancies in the submitted information, the form may be rejected, and the director will be required to correct the errors and resubmit the form.
  
• Late Filing Consequences: If the DIR-3 KYC form is filed after the due date (generally 30th September), a late fee of Rs. 5,000 is applicable. In such cases, the DIN remains deactivated due to non-filing until the form is submitted and the late fee is paid.
  

Key Points to Remember:

• Save the SRN and acknowledgment receipt for future reference.
  
• Check your email for approval or any further instructions from MCA.
  
• If filed late, ensure payment of the prescribed penalty to reactivate your DIN.
  

Conclusion

Filing your DIR-3 KYC might feel like just another task, but it plays a big role in keeping things smooth and compliant for you as a company director. It helps the government maintain updated records, ensures transparency, and keeps your Director Identification Number (DIN) active.

If you miss the September 30 deadline, your DIN can be deactivated, which means you won’t be able to sign documents or carry out official duties as a director. So, take a few minutes each year to check your details, fill out the form, and stay compliant.

Frequently Asked Questions