Difference Between BRC and FIRC – The New FIRA & e-BRC Rules

You receive a payment from your US client, but getting the right paperwork feels more complicated than closing the actual deal. Your chartered accountant asks for an FIRC, the bank says they issue FIRA, and DGFT mentions something about e-BRC.

These three acronyms, FIRC (Foreign Inward Remittance Certificate), FIRA (Foreign Inward Remittance Advice), and BRC (Bank Realisation Certificate), serve different purposes in export compliance. Most exporters mistakenly ask for an FIRC when they actually need a FIRA or ‘Advice’ for trade transactions, as banks stopped issuing physical FIRCs for exports in 2016.

Recent DGFT updates have shifted e-BRC generation to a self-certification model, changing how you claim export benefits. This guide clarifies the exact difference between brc and firc, explains the role of FIRA, and walks you through the modern compliance process.

What are FIRC, FIRA, and BRC?

While the introduction touched on the confusion around these documents, understanding their distinct roles requires examining each certificate individually. The banking system uses different documents for different types of foreign remittances, and knowing which one applies to your transaction prevents delays in compliance.

What is an FIRC?

Foreign Inward Remittance Certificate (FIRC) is a physical certificate issued by Authorised Dealer (AD) Category-I banks. This document serves specific purposes in today’s regulatory framework:

• Strictly for Capital Account transactions like Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) or Foreign Institutional Investment (FII)
  • Rarely issued for routine export payments anymore
  • Physical format requiring manual processing
  • Used primarily for proving capital infusion or non-trade receipts

What is a FIRA (formerly FIRC for exports)?

Foreign Inward Remittance Advice (FIRA) replaced the traditional FIRC for export transactions:

• Digital or physical advice slip banks issue for ‘Current Account’ transactions (export of goods/services)
  • The document exporters actually receive to prove payment receipt to authorities
  • Often called ‘FIRC’ colloquially, causing widespread confusion
  • Available as electronic advice in most modern banks
  • Essential for GST refund claims and tax compliance

What is a BRC?

Bank Realisation Certificate (BRC) serves a completely different purpose from payment proof:

• Links the incoming payment (FIRA) to the export documentation (Shipping Bill or SOFTEX)
  • Mandatory for claiming export incentives like RoDTEP and GST refunds
  • Now issued digitally as ‘e-BRC’ through the DGFT portal
  • Proves that export proceeds have been realised against specific shipments

While FIRC/FIRA proves money came in, BRC proves the export cycle is complete and obligations are fulfilled.

What is the difference between BRC and FIRC?

Having established what each document represents, the key distinctions become clearer when examined systematically. These differences impact how you request documents from banks and which ones you need for specific compliance requirements.

Difference #1: Primary Purpose

• FIRC/FIRA: Acts as a receipt. It proves that foreign currency entered the Indian banking system
  • BRC: Acts as a settlement proof. It proves that the specific export invoice has been fully paid and the transaction is closed

Difference #2: Issuance Workflow

• FIRC/FIRA: Issued by the bank immediately upon crediting the inward remittance to your account
  • BRC: Generated only after the exporter or bank maps the inward payment (FIRA) to the Shipping Bill or SOFTEX form

Difference #3: Regulatory Use Cases

• FIRC: Required for FDI compliance and proving capital infusion
  • FIRA: Required to prove zero-rated supply for GST refunds
  • BRC: Mandatory for DGFT incentives (RoDTEP, old MEIS/SEIS) and removing the exporter’s name from the RBI’s EDPMS defaulter list

Explore Razorpay’s Global Payment Solutions

The 2016 Shift: Why you get FIRA instead of FIRC

The distinction between FIRC and its modern replacements stems from a fundamental regulatory change in India’s export monitoring system. The Reserve Bank of India launched the Export Data Processing and Monitoring System (EDPMS) in 2016, completely transforming how banks handle export documentation.

Banks received instructions to stop issuing physical FIRCs for trade transactions as part of the broader digitisation initiative. Instead, they now issue ‘FIRA’ or ‘Inward Remittance Message (IRM)’, which serves as the standard proof for exporters. This change aimed to streamline processes and reduce paperwork delays that plagued traditional systems.

The practical impact remains significant today. When you ask a bank for an ‘FIRC’ for a service export, they might reject the request or express confusion. Asking for an ‘Advice’ or ‘FIRA’ accurately reflects the current documentation standards and ensures faster processing.

How to obtain FIRC (FIRA) and BRC?

The documentation process has evolved significantly from manual bank visits to digital self-service portals. Understanding both traditional and modern methods helps you choose the most efficient path for your business needs.

Method 1: The Traditional Bank Process

The conventional approach still followed by many exporters involves multiple steps:

1. Submit a request letter to your bank with transaction details (UTR, Purpose Code)
2. Pay the issuance fee (ranges from ₹200 to ₹1,000+ per certificate)
3. Wait 7-15 days for the physical or emailed FIRA
4. For BRC, log in to the DGFT portal, view the IRM uploaded by the bank, and self-certify to generate the e-BRC

Common delays occur when banks cannot match remittances due to missing UTR references on invoices. Providing remittance advice, invoice, and shipping bill details to your bank immediately prevents these issues.

Method 2: Razorpay MoneySaver Export Account (Automated)

Modern payment platforms eliminate manual processes through automation:

• FIRA/electronic advice generates automatically for every transaction
  • Documents available for download instantly from the dashboard
  • No additional cost compared to traditional bank fees
  • Eliminates the 7-15 day wait time, enabling faster reconciliation for GST refunds

The automated approach particularly benefits businesses processing multiple international transactions monthly, as manual certificate requests become unsustainable at scale.

Why are these documents mandatory for exporters?

Beyond the workflow differences, these certificates serve critical compliance functions that directly impact your business operations and cash flow. Missing or incorrect documentation triggers cascading problems across multiple regulatory requirements.

• GST Refund Requirements: You cannot claim a refund of accumulated ITC or IGST without proof of foreign remittance (FIRA/BRC). Check what is the difference between brc and firc for detailed GST implications.
• Export Incentive Claims: Schemes like RoDTEP require valid e-BRCs linked to shipping bills. Without proper BRC documentation, incentive claims face automatic rejection.
• FEMA Compliance: RBI requires all export proceeds to be realised within nine months. The BRC serves as definitive proof of this realisation, preventing EDPMS defaulter listing.
• Audit Trail Defence: FIRA and BRC serve as primary evidence during tax audits to prove income derives from exports and qualifies for zero-rating. Missing documents can trigger reassessments and penalties.

Automating Compliance with Razorpay MoneySaver Export Account

Manual compliance processes consume valuable time that exporters could invest in growing their businesses. Razorpay automatically generates an electronic FIRA (Foreign Inward Remittance Advice) for every international payment received, completely eliminating the need for manual request letters or bank visits. This automation addresses the primary pain point of exporters who spend days chasing banks for basic documentation.

Exporters can download their remittance advice instantly from the dashboard, which significantly speeds up the reconciliation process required for GST refunds and e-BRC generation. The platform’s integration with banking systems ensures that all necessary fields, including purpose codes and remitter details, populate correctly without manual intervention.

The account provides these essential compliance documents at no additional cost, removing the per-certificate issuance fees typically charged by traditional banks. For businesses receiving multiple payments monthly, this cost saving compounds significantly while reducing administrative burden.

Conclusion

Understanding the difference between brc and firc prevents compliance delays and penalty risks for Indian exporters. FIRC serves capital account transactions, FIRA proves trade payment receipts, and BRC confirms export realisation against specific shipping bills. The modern workflow follows a clear sequence: payment receipt generates FIRA, which enables DGFT self-certification for e-BRC generation.

Leveraging automation tools reduces the administrative burden of chasing banks for certificates while ensuring audit-ready documentation. Start by reviewing your current documentation process against compliance requirements, then explore digital solutions like Razorpay that eliminate manual certificate requests and accelerate GST refund cycles.

FAQs:

1. What is the main difference between FIRC and BRC?

FIRC (or FIRA) serves as proof that foreign currency has entered your bank account, whereas a BRC acts as proof that a specific export obligation has been legally fulfilled and reconciled against a shipping bill.

2. Is FIRC mandatory for claiming GST refunds on exports?

Yes, proof of foreign inward remittance is mandatory to claim GST refunds; however, for trade transactions, this proof is now provided as a FIRA or Inward Remittance Advice rather than a physical FIRC.

3. Why do banks refuse to issue physical FIRCs for service exports?

Following 2016 RBI guidelines, banks transitioned to the Export Data Processing and Monitoring System (EDPMS), replacing physical FIRCs for trade with digital FIRAs or advice slips to streamline compliance and digitisation.

4. How do I generate an e-BRC under the new DGFT rules?

Exporters must log in to the DGFT portal, locate the Inward Remittance Message (IRM) uploaded by their bank, and self-certify the payment against their Shipping Bill or SOFTEX form to generate the e-BRC. See DGFT FAQs on Self Certification of eBRC for detailed steps.

5. Can I claim export incentives without a BRC?

No, a valid Bank Realisation Certificate (BRC) is strictly required to claim benefits under government schemes like RoDTEP and to close open entries in the RBI EDPMS system.

6. How long does it take to get a FIRA from a traditional bank?

Obtaining a FIRA from a traditional bank typically involves a manual request process and can take between 7 to 15 days, often accompanied by an issuance fee per document ranging from ₹200 to ₹1,000.